Court rules on loss of hard drive with 7500 BTC
Since 2013, Howells has fought to gain permission to search the Newport landfill for the hard drive
James Howells, an IT engineer from Newport, Wales, has lost his long-running legal battle to recover a hard drive containing over $770 million worth of Bitcoin.
The hard drive, which holds Bitcoin mined in 2009, was mistakenly discarded in 2013 and ended up in a local landfill. According to BBC, despite repeated requests to a landfill closed by environmental authorities, Howells was denied by the Newport City Council, and his latest legal effort to retrieve the hard drive was dismissed by Judge Keyser, the Circuit Commercial Judge for Wales.
Details of the court case
Judge Keyser ruled that Howells’ case lacked a "realistic prospect" of success. The judge’s decision effectively ends a decade-long legal struggle to reclaim a lost fortune.
Bitcoin’s Meteoric Rise: Howells mined 8,000 BTC when the cryptocurrency was worth mere cents. By 2024, Bitcoin’s price surged dramatically, reaching highs of $100,000, increasing the value of the lost Bitcoin to over $770 million.
Howells had offered the Newport City Council a share of the Bitcoin if the hard drive could be recovered, but his repeated requests were rejected. The Council cited environmental concerns, with excavating the landfill potentially breaching environmental permits.
Lack of perspective in a legal battle
Since 2013, Howells has fought to gain permission to search the Newport landfill for the hard drive. His legal battle gained renewed attention in 2024, particularly during Bitcoin’s record rally, which pushed its price above $100,000. Despite claims of environmental violations by the council and offering evidence, Howells was unable to persuade the courts or the local government to allow excavation. The council, citing environmental risks, has steadfastly denied his request.
The decision has drawn attention not only for its financial implications but also for the intersection of legal, environmental, and technological factors in modern disputes. Howells had hoped to make history by retrieving a lost Bitcoin fortune, but the case has now ended with no clear resolution in his favor.
This ruling is likely to serve as a cautionary tale for both cryptocurrency investors and municipalities dealing with similar issues. The legal complexities surrounding digital assets and their recovery remain unresolved, but the case’s outcome emphasizes the importance of precaution and record-keeping when handling valuable assets, especially in the emerging world of cryptocurrency.
Reminder, Bitcoin price dips to $92.8K as ETF outflows hit $569 million in one day.
