In order to trade successfully, it is very important to choose the right broker. in Pakistan, a large number of companies provide access to trading and you will have to choose the one for you among them. It is important to work only with reliable brokers providing all the required instruments for trading based on your trading strategy. TU analysts have selected the best stock brokers for short selling in Pakistan 2024. You can compare their features and trading conditions.
1
Revolut - Best for short selling in Pakistan
Revolut is a British fintech company that has been providing investors with accounts for trading precious metals, cryptocurrencies, and stocks listed on U.S. exchanges since 2015. The broker offers its clients access to investing in stocks and ETFs on European stock exchanges. For organizations and private clients, the company offers a multi-currency account with the possibility of exchanging currencies at the current inter-bank exchange rate. Revolut is supervised by the Financial Services Authority (FSA).
👍 Advantages of trading with Revolut for traders from Pakistan:
•In addition to stock trades, customers can trade cryptocurrencies and precious metals.
•The broker offers commission-free trading plans.
•The minimum number of shares to buy is 0.00000001.
•There are no minimum deposit requirements.
•Social trading is available, which allows newcomers to the stock market to copy trades of successful traders.
•Communication with the support service via chat is available in the mobile application 24 hours a day.
•There is no fee for opening and maintaining a trading account.
👎 Disadvantages of Revolut for traders from Pakistan:
•Stock trading is currently only available to UK residents.
•Operations in precious metals and cryptocurrencies are not regulated by supervisory authorities.
•The company does not offer fiduciary management of its investment portfolio.
2
Interactive Brokers - Best for short selling in Pakistan
Interactive Brokers is among the best-known US investment companies, operating since 1977. The broker offers to trade currency pairs, but its basic instruments are stocks, CFD, indices, metals, ETF, futures, and other exchange market assets. The company is regulated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the US Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), the UK Financial Regulatory Authority (FCA, 208159), and other international financial regulation commissions. In 2020, the broker was awarded the "Best Online Broker” (Barron's) and "Best Broker for Economical Investments" (NerdWallet) titles and got five stars in the Online Stock Trading for Traders category (Canstar). Also, the broker is popular in other countries. Here you can read reviews of Interactive Brokers in Canada, Singapore, Australia, Hong Kong, Ireland.
👍 Advantages of trading with Interactive Brokers for traders from Pakistan:
•wide range of training materials;
•access to 135 markets in 33 countries;
•a huge subset of trading instruments.
👎 Disadvantages of Interactive Brokers for traders from Pakistan:
•website interface is only partially translated into other languages;
•you have to pay for an inactive account;
•Support service does not work on Saturday and Sunday;
•long and complex registration procedure;
•no cent accounts for novice traders.
3
Ninjatrader - Best for short selling in Pakistan
Ninja Trader is a Forex broker that has been providing brokerage services in the derivatives and foreign exchange markets since 2003. The main specialization of the company is in the futures and futures options markets. The broker is a licensed company with domicile in the United States. Ninja Trader also has offices in Germany and the Netherlands, but these are more representative functions.
👍 Advantages of trading with Ninjatrader for traders from Pakistan:
•availability of algorithmic trading using proprietary systems; there are more than 850;
•proprietary trading platform, which is one of the best products for trading in the derivatives markets (like MetaTrader 4 for Forex).
👎 Disadvantages of Ninjatrader for traders from Pakistan:
•high trading costs. In addition to the commission for the contract, there are exchange and regulatory fees, a fee to the trade provider (intermediary broker);
•the initial deposit is from USD 400. But that amount has nothing to do with fees associated with the US stock market;
•the broker is tailored exclusively for the US futures and options markets;
•a deep understanding of the principles of the derivatives market and the rules for working with exchanges is required;
•chat and phones contacts are missing;
•there are cases of neglect of client risks. Ninja Trader was fined in 2014 by its regulator for irregularities under its rules.
4
Collective2 - Best for short selling in Pakistan
The Collective2 brokerage company started its operations in 2001. It was founded by the American businessman Matthew Klein. It is a member of the NFA 0401602 (National Futures Association) and is regulated by the CFTC (Commodity Futures Trading Commission). The company is headquartered in New York. Today, Collective2 is a global platform that unites successful traders and investors who prefer to make money from sharing trading strategies. The broker provides services for over 100,000 active and passive clients in the stock market.
👍 Advantages of trading with Collective2 for traders from Pakistan:
•The broker is registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that regularly monitors its business transactions concerning its clients.
•The commission paid to the managing traders for their trading strategies is 50%.
•If necessary, you can make trades by phone.
•Collective2 technology is compatible with 16 brokers.
•By popular demand, the broker integrated multiple trading platforms.
•Weekly webinars feature highly topical Forex issues.
👎 Disadvantages of Collective2 for traders from Pakistan:
•There are no cent accounts.
•You can’t withdraw funds using e-payment systems.
•Sometimes you have to wait for a long time for a response from the support team.
5
J.P. Morgan - Best for short selling in Pakistan
The J.P. Morgan Self-Directed Investing service is in the brokerage division of JPMorgan Chase & Co Financial Corporation, and it offers investment services through JP Morgan Securities LLC (JPMS). The broker is part of one of the largest and oldest financial services corporations in the United States, with a reputation for transparency, accountability, and reliability. The broker provides services of long-term and retirement investment in securities within the USA market, services of active trading, and portfolio algorithmic investing. Trading assets are stocks of companies, ETF-fund shares, options, securities of retirement and investment funds, treasury notes, bills, US, corporate, and municipal bonds, derivatives, secondary market assets, etc.
👍 Advantages of trading with J.P. Morgan for traders from Pakistan:
•Flexible and clear tariff policy. For private investing the deposit is from $1, for automatic portfolio investing the deposit amount is from $500.
•Strict regulation. The SEC regulates J.P. Morgan Self-Directed Investing, and it is a member of FINRA CRD#: 79/SEC#: 801-3702,8-35008 and SIPC (the investor compensation fund). The broker is also subject to an annual external audit and is controlled by an exchange auditor.
•Offers trading accounts and retirement accounts.
•Automated Investing is an investment option that ensures that an investment portfolio follows the criteria set by the investor. The brokers’ analysts manage the portfolio.
•Additional products. Every broker's client can take advantage of other investment and financial offers from concessional lending to the development of a personal financial plan and trust management services.
👎 Disadvantages of J.P. Morgan for traders from Pakistan:
•The services are only available to U.S. residents. Possible schemes to work through intermediary funds/companies lead to a significant increase in the trade cost.
•Emphasis on financial products. Technological trading tools go into the background.
Commissions & Fees
Brokerage fees are the amount of money that you pay for using the services that a brokerage offers in order to perform trading and manage investments. The brokerage fee structure and regulations vary from broker to broker, and there are two primary fee types which are:
Trading Fees: This type of fee is only charged when you perform a trade. It can be a conversion fee, margin rate, financing rate, spread, or commission.
Non-Trading Fees: This type of fee isn't directly related to your trading activity, and it can include inactivity fee, withdrawal fee, deposit fee, etcetera.
Revolut Commissions and Fees
During our analysis of trading conditions, it was found that Revolut limits the number of trades without commissions. Depending on the account type, 1-5 transactions per month are free. There is a monthly subscription fee of £2.99-£12.99 on different accounts, which can be reduced by 20% if you pay in advance for a year. The broker charges a fee of 1 USD for additional orders. Since stocks listed on American exchanges are offered for investment, the fees are calculated in USD and then the funds are converted to the account currency at the current exchange rate. For transactions in cryptocurrency, the commission is 1.5-2%, and for transactions in precious metals, it’s 0.5-1.5% of the transaction volume. The amount of interest depends on the selected trading account. No additional hidden commissions were revealed.
| Account type | Spread (minimum value) | Withdrawal commision |
|---|---|---|
|
Standard |
From £2.99 |
No |
|
Plus |
From £2.99 |
No |
|
Premium |
From £2.99 |
No |
|
Metals |
From £2.99 |
No |
Interactive Brokers Commissions and Fees
Traders Union analysts have verified Interactive Brokers for hidden fees and assessed the commission level in the company. The company charges $20 for an inactive account if there is less than $2,000 on the account and $10 if there is more than $2,000. You can withdraw funds for free once a month; if you withdraw funds more often, you’ll have to pay a commission, the amount of which varies depending on the base currency of the account and the payment system.
| Account type | Spread (minimum value) | Withdrawal commision |
|---|---|---|
|
Real |
From $2 |
Depending on the currency and withdrawal method |
Ninjatrader Commissions and Fees
Experts at Traders Union have analyzed NinjaTrader conditions for explicit and implicit fees. There are no hidden fees. Since the broker is an intermediary on the US and European stock exchanges, it is not responsible for the level of the spread and there is no data on the site. There are additional commissions of exchanges, banks, partners, and brokers-partners.
| Account type | Spread (minimum value) | Withdrawal commision |
|---|---|---|
|
Futures |
$50 for ‘mini’ contracts |
Yes |
|
Options |
From $0,59 |
No |
Collective2 Commissions and Fees
The experts at Traders Union examined Collective2 for explicit and hidden commissions and found the following. The broker provides a two-week trial period. After it expires, you should purchase one of the packaged services. It cost from $19 to $99. Moreover, the company charges a trade opening fee of 2%. There is no commission for opening an account, replenishing a deposit, or withdrawing funds from Collective2.
| Account type | Spread (minimum value) | Withdrawal commision |
|---|---|---|
|
Starter |
From $2 |
No |
|
Basic |
From $2 |
No |
|
Premium |
From $2 |
No |
J.P. Morgan Commissions and Fees
Analysts at the Traders Union examined J.P. Morgan's Self-Directed Investing pricing policy and highlighted the main fees for both investment options. The main fee is a management commission of 0.35% of the investment portfolio amount per year. For Self-Directed Investing, depending on the type of asset, (for the primary market) the commissions range from $20-$25 per transaction + $0.65 per contract for trading in pending orders. Commissions for market orders start from $0.65 per contract without a minimum charge. For transactions with secondary market assets such as municipal and corporate bonds, the minimum commission is $10 + $1 for each bond.
| Account type | Spread (minimum value) | Withdrawal commision |
|---|---|---|
|
Self-Directed Investing |
from $0.65 |
No |
|
Automated Investing |
from $0.15/month |
No |
Summary
Many brokers are available for traders from Pakistan, but not all of them offer good conditions. In this review, TU experts chose the Best stock brokers for short selling in Pakistan 2024. These are the most trusted companies that offer the best conditions for traders. You will also be able to review the general assessment of each broker.
Overall score of the best Stock Brokers For Short Selling in Pakistan
| Revolut | Interactive Brokers | Ninjatrader | Collective2 | J.P. Morgan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Overall score |
7.69 |
7.45 |
7.03 |
6.01 |
4.48 |
|
Execution of orders |
9.2 |
8.8 |
8.1 |
6.99 |
4.84 |
|
Investment instruments |
9.8 |
9.4 |
8.7 |
7.41 |
5.26 |
|
Withdrawal speed |
9.6 |
9.2 |
8.5 |
7.05 |
4.9 |
|
Customer Support work |
9.4 |
9 |
8.3 |
7.35 |
5.2 |
|
Variety of instruments |
9.1 |
8.7 |
8 |
6.83 |
4.68 |
|
Trading platform |
9.9 |
9.5 |
8.8 |
7.57 |
5.42 |
|
|
|||||
|
|
FAQ
How much money do I need in order to start working in the financial markets?
The initial capital depends on the assets you plan to trade. However, in the majority of cases, $300-500 is a good amount for a start.
What commissions and fees should I take into consideration when I am choosing a broker?
The commissions and fees in the financial markets are divided into trading and non-tradings ones. Trading fees are the fees that are charged directly during trading (spread, commission per lot, etc.), while non-trading fees are the ones charged outside the trading process (for example, account fee, inactivity fee, deposit and withdrawal fee).
What learning instruments can a broker offer?
Brokers offer various educational options. These include full-fledged educational courses, or video tutorials, articles, and books. Companies also often hold seminars and webinars.
Can you earn passive income in the financial markets?
Yes, the best brokers in Pakistan offer passive income options. These could include copy trading, PAMM accounts, managed portfolios, etc.
Best Stock Brokers For Short Selling by Countries
Related Articles
Team that worked on the article
Mikhail Vnuchkov joined Traders Union as an author in 2020. He began his professional career as a journalist-observer at a small online financial publication, where he covered global economic events and discussed their impact on the segment of financial investment, including investor income. With five years of experience in finance, Mikhail joined Traders Union team, where he is in charge of forming the pool of latest news for traders, who trade stocks, cryptocurrencies, Forex instruments and fixed income.
Olga Shendetskaya has been a part of the Traders Union team as an author, editor and proofreader since 2017. Since 2020, Shendetskaya has been the assistant chief editor of the website of Traders Union, an international association of traders. She has over 10 years of experience of working with economic and financial texts. In the period of 2017-2020, Olga has worked as a journalist and editor of laftNews news agency, economic and financial news sections. At the moment, Olga is a part of the team of top industry experts involved in creation of educational articles in finance and investment, overseeing their writing and publication on the Traders Union website.