Is scalping trading legal or illegal?

What is scalping in trading?

Scalping is a trading strategy that involves buying and selling assets within a short time. It requires quick decision-making skills, market analysis, and risk-taking. The main differences between scalping and other trading systems are timeframe, frequency, profit margin, and risk management. Broadly, scalping is a high-risk, high-reward strategy that requires skill, experience, and discipline, and is not suitable for everyone.

Is scalping trading legal or illegal?

Legally, scalping is not restricted, but some brokers may impose restrictions on it due to the higher risk associated with the strategy. Specifically, some brokers may set limits on the number of trades a trader can make in a given day or a limit on the amount of time a position can be held for. In addition, some brokers may ban scalping altogether or may set restrictions on scalping.

Some countries have implemented legislature that restricts certain types of trading strategies, such as 'spoofing,' which is an illegal form of scalping. Spoofing involves placing a buy or sell order and then quickly canceling it in an attempt to manipulate the market. The majority of countries have laws in place to prevent this kind of market manipulation.

Why do some brokers not allow scalping?

Scalping can be a profitable trading strategy, but some brokers choose to prohibit or limit it due to a few reasons. Firstly, high-frequency trading, which is a crucial aspect of scalping, can put a significant strain on a broker's server. This is because it generates a large volume of trades and orders, which can increase the load on the server, causing slow speeds or even outages. As a result, some brokers may choose to limit scalping to protect their trading platform's stability and ensure the smooth operation of the system.

Another reason why some brokers do not allow scalping is that it may not be profitable for them, particularly for brokers who operate on a B-Book scheme. In such a scheme, the broker takes the opposite position of their clients, which means they make a profit when their clients lose money. However, scalping can be a more profitable trading strategy for clients, as it involves a high frequency of opening deals that can generate significant profits, even if the margins are small. Therefore, some brokers may prohibit or restrict scalping to minimize the impact of potentially profitable strategies on their bottom line.

The broker prohibits scalping: what does it mean?

If a broker prohibits scalping, it means that they have set restrictions on the use of this trading strategy on their platform. This can be due to several reasons, including the broker's technical capabilities and business model.

Firstly, a broker that prohibits scalping may have poor technical equipment, which can lead to increased server load and impact the quality of execution of transactions. Scalping involves a high frequency of trades and orders, which can generate a significant volume of data and increase the load on the broker's server. This can cause slow execution speeds, requotes, and other issues that can negatively affect the trader's experience on the platform.

Secondly, the broker may not benefit from the trader's profitability, which suggests that they are not acting as an intermediary between the trader and the market. Instead, they may be operating as a "kitchen" or counterparty to the trader's transactions, meaning that they make a profit when the trader loses money. In this case, scalping may not be profitable for the broker, especially when the traders stay profitable. This leads brokers into disincentivizing scalping.

How to find out if a broker prohibits scalping?

To determine if a broker prohibits scalping, traders can check the broker's trading conditions or offers. Brokers usually state their policies on scalping in fine print, which is readily available on their website or trading platform.

When reviewing a broker's scalping policy, traders should look for possible restrictions that can affect their trading strategy. These restrictions may include the minimum time for a trade to be held in the market, the minimum stop length, or limitations on the use of scalping advisors.

For example, some brokers may require traders to hold a position for a certain amount of time, such as 1-2 minutes, before closing it. This can impact the effectiveness of a scalping strategy, as scalpers aim to make quick profits from short-term trades. Similarly, brokers may impose a minimum stop length, which means that traders cannot place stop-loss orders below a certain level, which can limit the flexibility of the strategy.

Best brokers no restrictions on trading strategies

1

9.4/10

Go to broker

eToro is a multi-asset investment platform. The value of your investments may go up or down. Your capital is at risk. Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest.

Minimum deposit:

$50, $100 (for UK clients)

Bonus for deposit:

0%

Regulation:

CySEC, FCA, ASIC

Review

The eToro broker was founded in 2007. The company promotes itself as a social trading platform working with traders from over 140 countries. The broker has several divisions operating under different jurisdictions and licensed by different regulators. For example, eToro (Europe) is licensed by the Cypriot regulator CySEC (109/10) and eToro (UK) is licensed by the British regulator FCA (583263). The broker also has a representative office in Australia and the USA. eToro Profile Details

Pros/Cons

•the minimum transaction amount for copying is $1;

•handy functionality for passive investing;

•regulated by independent monitors;

•it is possible to purchase contracts for fractional shares (that is, to invest amounts less than the cost of one share);

•it is possible to buy shares at once (not CFDs) on the US stock exchanges.

•high spreads;

•periodic technical failures in order execution;

•lack of the most popular platforms such as MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 in Europe and the CIS;

•no access to ECN systems, orders are processed only according to the STP (straight-through processing) scheme with access to specific liquidity providers;

•there is a commission for withdrawing funds;

•impolite support staff;

•inconvenient website.

Study Review

2

9.2/10

Go to broker

Your capital is at risk.

Minimum deposit:

No minimum

Bonus for deposit:

0%

Regulation:

FSC (BVI), ASIC, IIROC, FCA, CFTC, NFA

Review

The name OANDA is an acronym for “Olsen & Associates” or “Olsen AND Associates”. It is registered in the United States and provides its clients with a wide range of financial services in most countries of the world. The company was founded in 1996 and is currently regulated in four jurisdictions. The main regulator of the broker is the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Oanda Canada is licensed by IIROC. The company has several significant awards to its credit, including a victory in the category "Best Forex Trading Technologies" from the UK Forex Awards, "Best Trading Platform" from FX Week, as well as "Best Customer Service" from the US Foreign Exchange Report.

Pros/Cons

•Minimum deposit from 1 dollar.

•A large selection of the most popular trading instruments.

•Several reliable and reputable financial regulators.

•Inconvenient and poorly functioning site.

•Lack of cent accounts.

•Lack of bonus programs.

Study Review