Best Investment Broker For Fractional Shares In Italy 2024 - TOP 5 Comparison

1
7.75
Your capital is at risk.
eToro is a multi-asset platform which offers both investing in stocks and cryptoassets, as well as trading CFDs.
2
7.69
3
7.21
Share this:
Editorial Note: While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here's an explanation for How We Make Money. None of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer.

In order to trade successfully, it is very important to choose the right broker. in Italy, a large number of companies provide access to trading and you will have to choose the one for you among them. It is important to work only with reliable brokers providing all the required instruments for trading based on your trading strategy. TU analysts have selected the best investment brokers for fractional shares in Italy 2024. You can compare their features and trading conditions.

1
eToro - Best for fractional shares in Italy

VISIT BROKER
Your capital is at risk.
eToro is a multi-asset platform which offers both investing in stocks and cryptoassets, as well as trading CFDs.

The eToro broker was founded in 2007. The company promotes itself as a social trading platform working with traders from over 140 countries. The broker has several divisions operating under different jurisdictions and licensed by different regulators. For example, eToro (Europe) is licensed by the Cypriot regulator CySEC (109/10) and eToro (UK) is licensed by the British regulator FCA (583263). The broker also has a representative office in Australia and the USA.

👍 Advantages of trading with eToro for traders from Italy:

High level of reliability ensured by the licenses of respected regulatory authorities and participation in the compensation funds.

Wide selection of assets quoted at stock exchanges in the UK, U.S., Australia and Asia.

An opportunity to combine active trading with social trading and passive investing.

Zero-fee trading of a number of stocks.

Access to ready-made diversified asset portfolios with various risk levels.

Provision of leverage, educational materials on various markets and user-friendly trading platforms that can run on any device.

Zero fees for portfolio management, depositing funds and account maintenance.

👎 Disadvantages of eToro for traders from Italy:

High minimum deposit for users of a number of countries.

No live chat on the website for quick connection to customer support.

2
Revolut - Best for fractional shares in Italy

Revolut is a British fintech company that has been providing investors with accounts for trading precious metals, cryptocurrencies, and stocks listed on U.S. exchanges since 2015. The broker offers its clients access to investing in stocks and ETFs on European stock exchanges. For organizations and private clients, the company offers a multi-currency account with the possibility of exchanging currencies at the current inter-bank exchange rate. Revolut is supervised by the Financial Services Authority (FSA).

👍 Advantages of trading with Revolut for traders from Italy:

In addition to stock trades, customers can trade cryptocurrencies and precious metals.

The broker offers commission-free trading plans.

The minimum number of shares to buy is 0.00000001.

There are no minimum deposit requirements.

Social trading is available, which allows newcomers to the stock market to copy trades of successful traders.

Communication with the support service via chat is available in the mobile application 24 hours a day.

There is no fee for opening and maintaining a trading account.

👎 Disadvantages of Revolut for traders from Italy:

Stock trading is currently only available to UK residents.

Operations in precious metals and cryptocurrencies are not regulated by supervisory authorities.

The company does not offer fiduciary management of its investment portfolio.

3
Fidelity - Best for fractional shares in Italy

Fidelity Investments is a large American financial services company. It was founded in 1946 by American businessman and lawyer Edward Crosby Johnson II. It provides services to traders in trading securities and commodity assets and allows investors to invest in mutual funds and investment funds, form portfolios for a variety of instruments, including bonds and annuities with fixed income. The company has received several awards: according to Barron's, Investors Business Daily, Kiplinger, and Stock Brokers. Fidelity Investments is recognized as the best online broker of 2020.

👍 Advantages of trading with Fidelity for traders from Italy:

availability of its own trading terminal for active trading, Active Trader Pro, with advanced analytics from experts and a wide range of technical analysis tools;

no brokerage fee for consulting services with an account balance of up to $10,000, and only $3 if a larger deposit is made;

there is the possibility of individual planning for investors, while the cost of the service is 0.5% of the size of the deposit for each month of use.

👎 Disadvantages of Fidelity for traders from Italy:

lack of localization;

there are no active bonus programs; nor is there an opportunity to receive additional profit for attracting new customers;

margin trading is possible if the account balance exceeds 250 thousand dollars;

the demo account is limited in functionality and involves working only with investment portfolios.

4
Comdirect - Best for fractional shares in Italy

Comdirect is an investment bank and broker founded in 1994 that is owned and operated by the largest German bank Commerzbank AG. Comdirect is listed on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and regulated by BaFin, the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority. It offers clients accounts for Forex trading and investing in securities of the German, European and international markets. Comdirect has received numerous awards for its banking products and brokerage services. In 2021 they won the annual Euro am Sonntag and Broker-Wahl voting for the title of the best online broker.

👍 Advantages of trading with Comdirect for traders from Italy:

No minimum deposit requirements.

A wide range of investment assets for diversified portfolios.

Huge number of tools for advanced market analysis.

Ability to make transactions through a mobile application and third-party terminals.

Free withdrawal of funds from investment accounts.

Availability of an affiliate program and various bonus offers.

👎 Disadvantages of Comdirect for traders from Italy:

High trading commissions on all asset classes.

The broker does not have a website in English. Personal account, terminals, and communication with company representatives are conducted in German only.

Complex and lengthy process for opening an account for traders who are located outside of Germany and Austria.

5
BGL BNP Paribas - Best for fractional shares in Italy

The BGL BNP Paribas (hereinafter also referred to as “BBP”) broker is a subsidiary of the French financial conglomerate BNP Paribas Group, which is registered and operates in Luxembourg. The broker operates under the supervision of the European Securities Market Supervision Authority (ESMA). Its clients have the opportunity to invest in stocks, bonds, ETFs, precious metals, funds of the BNP Paribas Group, and funds of other issuers. The BBP group offers a wide range of banking, brokerage, and investment services, as well as financial advice and wealth management.

👍 Advantages of trading with BGL BNP Paribas for traders from Italy:

No deposit fees for Luxembourg citizens or foreign residents.

Provides a sample of funds that BBP thinks are reliable.

Possibility of round-the-clock placement of orders for trades on European and American exchanges (21 exchanges are offered).

Participation in the FGDL (Fonds de Garantie des Dépôts Luxembourg) deposit guarantee scheme, which involves payments of up to €100,000 for each investor.

Assistance by a personal consultant when contacting by phone or in a Web bank chat.

Opening a savings account to manage financial services is available in 11 currencies.

Access to the dynamic investment of deposits from a savings account.

👎 Disadvantages of BGL BNP Paribas for traders from Italy:

High requirements for the size of the minimum deposit, which must be at least €50,000.

There is no fixed brokerage fee.

The site lacks quality training on the basics of stock market trading.

Commissions & Fees

Brokerage fees are the amount of money that you pay for using the services that a brokerage offers in order to perform trading and manage investments. The brokerage fee structure and regulations vary from broker to broker, and there are two primary fee types which are:

Trading Fees: This type of fee is only charged when you perform a trade. It can be a conversion fee, margin rate, financing rate, spread, or commission.

Non-Trading Fees: This type of fee isn't directly related to your trading activity, and it can include inactivity fee, withdrawal fee, deposit fee, etcetera.

eToro Commissions and Fees

Information

Registration on the eToro platform is free. The broker does not charge a fee for opening and closing long positions on stocks quoted at the US stock exchanges. The stocks of other markets are available as derivatives, with eToro charging a trading fee on them in the form of the spread. Also, the fees are applied to short positions and leveraged orders. The company accepts and allows withdrawals of only US dollars. If a client deposits or withdraws another currency, it is converted into USD at a fee of 0-50 pips. Members of eToro club get a 50-100% fee reduction on conversion. If a client shows no activity for a period of 12 month, the broker charges the inactivity fee of $10. There is no deposit fee. eToro charges $5 on each withdrawal.

Account type Spread (minimum value) Withdrawal commision

Standard

$5

Yes

Pro

from $1.1

$5 eToro’s fee + the fees of payment systems

Revolut Commissions and Fees

Information

During our analysis of trading conditions, it was found that Revolut limits the number of trades without commissions. Depending on the account type, 1-5 transactions per month are free. There is a monthly subscription fee of £2.99-£12.99 on different accounts, which can be reduced by 20% if you pay in advance for a year. The broker charges a fee of 1 USD for additional orders. Since stocks listed on American exchanges are offered for investment, the fees are calculated in USD and then the funds are converted to the account currency at the current exchange rate. For transactions in cryptocurrency, the commission is 1.5-2%, and for transactions in precious metals, it’s 0.5-1.5% of the transaction volume. The amount of interest depends on the selected trading account. No additional hidden commissions were revealed.

Account type Spread (minimum value) Withdrawal commision

Standard

From £2.99

No

Plus

From £2.99

No

Premium

From £2.99

No

Metals

From £2.99

No

Fidelity Commissions and Fees

Information

The size of commissions for this broker varies depending on the traded instrument and for all types of accounts, ranging from 0 to 0.03% from every $1000 of turnover, plus $0.65 for each option contract. When trading medium-term and long-term US government bonds, a brokerage fee of $19.95 to $250 is charged for the entire volume of the trade. For Treasury securities maturing within a year, the commission is a maximum of $50.

Account type Spread (minimum value) Withdrawal commision

Traditional IRA

From $2

No

Rollover IRA

From $2

No

ROTH IRA

From $2

No

Brokerage Account

From $2

No

Brokerage and fund management

From $2

No

Account «529»

From $2

No

Fidelity Go

From $2

No

Fidelity personalized management and consulting

From $2

No

Comdirect Commissions and Fees

Information

Comdirect’s commission for trading stocks and ETFs consists of two parts: a percentage of the volume and a fixed fee per trade. The size of the trading commission varies depending on the instrument and the exchange.

  • For the purchase and sale of German stocks and ETFs, the broker withholds 0.25% of the transaction amount plus €4.9 per order (minimum €9.9; maximum €59.9).

  • Exchange commissions are 0.0025% of the turnover (minimum €2.5) or 0.005% (but not less than €5). 

  • For transactions with international stocks, the investor pays 0.25% of the volume, plus €7.9 per transaction (minimum €12.9; maximum €62.9) plus any third-party costs.

  • Commission for orders in terms of OTC trading is 0.25% plus €4.9 (minimum €9.9, maximum €59.9).

  • Each futures index or ETF and index option contract costs €4.5, and a stock futures contract costs €2.5. The minimum commission for futures and options is €19.

Comdirect does not charge any fees for account opening, deposits, or withdrawals. The inactivity fee is €0 during the first three years. After that, it is €1.95 per month, if the client has not completed 2 transactions per quarter or does not have a savings or current account with Commerzbank AG.

Account type Spread (minimum value) Withdrawal commision

Comdirect Depot

from 9.9€

no

Währungsanlagenkonto (Currency Asset Account)

from 12.9€

no

LiveTrading

from 9.9€

no

CFD-Konto

from 0€

no

BGL BNP Paribas Commissions and Fees

Information

Analysis of the trading conditions offered by BBP shows that the maintenance of a trading account for Luxembourg citizens is free of charge. However, for foreign customers there is a subscription fee of €3 or €15 per month, depending on the type of account. Wealth management services will cost 0.5% + 17% VAT on the investment per year. There is no commission for withdrawing funds to BBP bank accounts (including SEPA). Transferring money not via SEPA and to accounts of other banks costs from €0.75 to €5 per payment. Brokerage commissions are calculated as a percentage of the trade amount and are 2% for precious metals and 0.75% for other instruments, but not less than 50 EUR per transaction.

Account type Spread (minimum value) Withdrawal commision

Direct Invest+

From €50

Applied to certain international payments

Direct Invest+ International

From €50

Applied to certain international payments

Self Invest

From €50

Applied to certain international payments

Self Invest International

From €50

Applied to certain international payments

Summary

Many brokers are available for traders from Italy, but not all of them offer good conditions. In this review, TU experts chose the Best investment brokers for fractional shares in Italy 2024. These are the most trusted companies that offer the best conditions for traders. You will also be able to review the general assessment of each broker.

Overall score of the best Investment Brokers For Fractional Shares in Italy

eToro Revolut Fidelity Comdirect BGL BNP Paribas

Overall score

7.75

7.69

7.21

5.05

5.08

Execution of orders

9.1

9.2

8.4

5.89

5.94

Investment instruments

9.7

9.8

9

6.31

6.36

Withdrawal speed

9.5

9.6

8.8

5.95

6

Customer Support work

9.3

9.4

8.6

6.25

6.3

Variety of instruments

9

9.1

8.3

5.73

5.78

Trading platform

9.8

9.9

9.1

6.47

6.52

eToro Review

Revolut Review

Fidelity Review

Comdirect Review

BGL BNP Paribas Review

Open an account

eToro is a multi-asset platform which offers both investing in stocks and cryptoassets, as well as trading CFDs.

FAQ

Can you earn passive income in the financial markets?

Yes, the best brokers in Italy offer passive income options. These could include copy trading, PAMM accounts, managed portfolios, etc.

What is a demo account and why is it important?

On a demo account, you trade by using virtual funds. It is important to choose a broker offering a demo account both for beginners, who are only learning, and for experienced traders, who can use this account type to test new strategies or EAs risk-free.

Is it possible to work with offshore brokers?

It is best not to work with offshore brokers. However, if you have chosen such a company, you need to check and analyze it very thoroughly. There are offshore brokers with good reputations. Before you start working with such a company, deposit the minimum amount and start trading. Once you’ve worked with the broker for a little while and checked how it operates and how quickly it processes withdrawals, you can start depositing higher amounts.

What commissions and fees should I take into consideration when I am choosing a broker?

The commissions and fees in the financial markets are divided into trading and non-tradings ones. Trading fees are the fees that are charged directly during trading (spread, commission per lot, etc.), while non-trading fees are the ones charged outside the trading process (for example, account fee, inactivity fee, deposit and withdrawal fee).

Team that worked on the article

Mikhail Vnuchkov
Author at Traders Union

Mikhail Vnuchkov joined Traders Union as an author in 2020. He began his professional career as a journalist-observer at a small online financial publication, where he covered global economic events and discussed their impact on the segment of financial investment, including investor income. With five years of experience in finance, Mikhail joined Traders Union team, where he is in charge of forming the pool of latest news for traders, who trade stocks, cryptocurrencies, Forex instruments and fixed income.

Olga Shendetskaya
Author and editor at Traders Union

Olga Shendetskaya has been a part of the Traders Union team as an author, editor and proofreader since 2017. Since 2020, Shendetskaya has been the assistant chief editor of the website of Traders Union, an international association of traders. She has over 10 years of experience of working with economic and financial texts. In the period of 2017-2020, Olga has worked as a journalist and editor of laftNews news agency, economic and financial news sections. At the moment, Olga is a part of the team of top industry experts involved in creation of educational articles in finance and investment, overseeing their writing and publication on the Traders Union website.