Understanding Cross Trading
Cross trading is a unique type of broker-side trade where they buy and sell an underlying at the same time, in a manner that both transactions offset each other. Such transactions are not recorded on the exchange, leaving non-participants unaware of their existence. As these disadvantages the broader market, most exchanges prohibit the act of cross trading.
Cross-trading, the practice of matching buy and sell orders within a single entity, is a dynamic and debated facet of financial markets. It offers cost-saving advantages but also raises important regulatory and ethical considerations. While cross trading is generally permitted in many countries under specific rules, its legality is highly constrained and varies. As a result, knowing where it is allowed and where it isn’t becomes a crucial consideration for market participants. So, in this article, the experts at TU will examine what cross trading is and its legal status globally. They will also explore why some places restrict or even ban cross-trading, shedding light on the controversies and concerns driving these regulatory decisions.
Do you want to start trading Forex? Open an account on RoboForex!What is cross-trading?
Cross trading refers to a financial practice where a broker or intermediary matches buy and sell orders for the same security or asset within their own client base or among affiliated accounts, without going through a public exchange. This type of trading can occur in various financial markets, including stocks, bonds, and commodities.
The primary motivation behind cross-trading is often to achieve cost savings and operational efficiencies. By matching orders internally, institutions can reduce transaction costs, such as exchange fees and bid-ask spreads, and minimize market impact, which is particularly important when dealing with large orders. This can be advantageous for institutional investors, such as mutual funds, pension funds, or asset managers, who seek to execute trades efficiently while minimizing the impact on the market price of the security.
However, it also raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest, as the broker or intermediary must prioritize fair execution for all parties involved. Therefore, regulatory bodies often impose strict rules and disclosure requirements to ensure transparency and fairness in cross-trading activities. Overall, cross-trading can be a useful tool for institutional investors, provided it is conducted with appropriate oversight and in compliance with regulatory guidelines.
Cross trading example
Imagine an investment bank with two clients: Client A and Client B. Client A owns a substantial number of shares in a tech company, while Client B is interested in purchasing those exact shares. Instead of sending Client A's sell order to a public stock exchange, which could impact the stock's price, the bank identifies an opportunity for cross-trading. They match Client A's sell order with Client B's buy order internally, executing the trade within their own client accounts. This way, both clients achieve their objectives without incurring additional exchange fees or causing market disruptions. To put legal requirements in the picture, the bank must ensure transparency by disclosing the cross trade and obtaining client consent as required by regulations.
Is cross-trading legal?
Cross-trades are typically not allowed on major stock exchanges, as orders must go through the exchange for recording. However, exceptions exist, such as when both buyer and seller are managed by the same asset manager or when the trade price is competitive. In such cases, the portfolio manager can transfer assets between clients to eliminate trade spreads. To comply with regulations, a fair market price must be established, and the trade recorded as a "cross trade”. Further, the asset manager must demonstrate that it benefits both parties.
Additional scenarios where cross-trades are permitted include transferring client assets between accounts (not reported on exchanges), hedging derivatives, and executing certain block orders. These exceptions allow for flexibility while maintaining regulatory compliance and fairness in the trading process.
In summary, cross-trading is legal when conducted in accordance with regulatory guidelines and ethical standards. However, it is subject to stringent regulations to safeguard the interests of clients and maintain the integrity of financial markets. Violations of these regulations can lead to fines, penalties, and legal consequences for the involved parties.
Why is cross-trading illegal in many exchanges?
While cross-trading is not inherently illegal, it has indeed been the subject of concerns in the financial industry. These concerns include:
Perceived lack of transparency
Cross-trading often occurs off-exchange and may not be as transparent as trades executed on public exchanges. This opacity can raise suspicions about whether the trade was conducted fairly, potentially eroding trust in the market.
Conflicts of interest
Cross-trading can create conflicts of interest for brokers, asset managers, or other intermediaries. When they match buy and sell orders within their own client base, questions may arise about whether they prioritize the interests of one client over the other, leading to concerns about fairness.
Market manipulation risks
In certain situations, cross-trading could be exploited for market manipulation, as it may be less scrutinized than trades conducted on public exchanges. This risk can undermine the market's integrity.
Regulatory scrutiny
Regulators closely monitor cross-trading to ensure compliance with rules and regulations. Instances of non-compliance can lead to legal issues and regulatory actions, further fuelling controversies.
It is important to note that while significant concerns exist, cross-trading is a legitimate practice when conducted within the bounds of regulatory frameworks and with proper oversight to ensure fairness and transparency. Market participants and regulators continue to work on refining the rules and guidelines governing cross-trading to address these concerns and maintain trust in the financial markets.
Best Forex brokers 2024
Summary
Cross-trading is a financial practice where a broker or intermediary matches buy and sell orders for the same security or asset within their own client base or affiliated accounts, bypassing public exchanges. This is done to reduce transaction costs and minimize market impact, benefiting institutional investors. However, cross-trading raises concerns about conflicts of interest, prompting strict regulatory oversight and disclosure requirements.
In a typical example, an investment bank matches a client with shares to sell (Client A) with another client looking to buy those shares (Client B) internally, avoiding exchange fees and market disruption. While not allowed on major stock exchanges, exceptions exist, such as when both parties are managed by the same asset manager. Cross-trades must establish a fair market price and be recorded as such.
Cross-trading is legal when adhering to regulations and ethical standards but is subject to scrutiny due to perceived lack of transparency, conflicts of interest, and market manipulation risks. Regulators aim to strike a balance between facilitating cost-effective trading and ensuring market integrity, evolving rules, and guidelines accordingly.
FAQs
Is cross-trading legal?
Cross trades are permitted when brokers are transferring client's assets between accounts, for derivatives trade hedges, and for certain block orders.
What does cross-trading mean?
A cross-trade takes place when a broker or portfolio manager effectively moves an asset from one client to another while removing the associated transaction spread. In simpler terms, it involves transferring assets between two distinct accounts without the need for them to go through a public market transaction.
What are the benefits of cross-trading?
Executing a cross-trade in compliance with legal and regulatory standards can lead to swift order execution with minimal delays and improved pricing. In this process, the broker or asset manager can counterbalance opposing orders for the same asset from its internal order book, all without the necessity of reporting the transaction to the exchange.
Is cross-trading illegal?
As a general rule, major stock exchanges do not allow cross-trades because they require orders to be sent directly to the exchange for proper recording. However, there are exceptions to this rule. One such exception is when both the seller and the buyer are under the management of the same asset manager. In such cases, cross-trades may be permitted.
Glossary for novice traders
-
1
Broker
A broker is a legal entity or individual that performs as an intermediary when making trades in the financial markets. Private investors cannot trade without a broker, since only brokers can execute trades on the exchanges.
-
2
Trading
Trading involves the act of buying and selling financial assets like stocks, currencies, or commodities with the intention of profiting from market price fluctuations. Traders employ various strategies, analysis techniques, and risk management practices to make informed decisions and optimize their chances of success in the financial markets.
-
3
Cross trading
Cross trading is a unique type of broker-side trade where they buy and sell an underlying at the same time, in a manner that both transactions offset each other. Such transactions are not recorded on the exchange, leaving non-participants unaware of their existence.
-
4
Investor
An investor is an individual, who invests money in an asset with the expectation that its value would appreciate in the future. The asset can be anything, including a bond, debenture, mutual fund, equity, gold, silver, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and real-estate property.
-
5
CFD
CFD is a contract between an investor/trader and seller that demonstrates that the trader will need to pay the price difference between the current value of the asset and its value at the time of contract to the seller.
Team that worked on the article
Chinmay Soni is a financial analyst with more than 5 years of experience in working with stocks, Forex, derivatives, and other assets. As a founder of a boutique research firm and an active researcher, he covers various industries and fields, providing insights backed by statistical data. He is also an educator in the field of finance and technology.
As an author for Traders Union, he contributes his deep analytical insights on various topics, taking into account various aspects.
Dr. BJ Johnson is a PhD in English Language and an editor with over 15 years of experience. He earned his degree in English Language in the U.S and the UK. In 2020, Dr. Johnson joined the Traders Union team. Since then, he has created over 100 exclusive articles and edited over 300 articles of other authors.
Mirjan Hipolito is a journalist and news editor at Traders Union. She is an expert crypto writer with five years of experience in the financial markets. Her specialties are daily market news, price predictions, and Initial Coin Offerings (ICO).