What are the Rules for Trading in Islam?

Is Forex trading halal or haram in Islam?

The permissibility of trading in Islam is a nuanced subject revolving around adherence to specific religious principles. Islamic finance assesses transactions based on compliance with Sharia law, prohibiting certain activities like usury (riba) and excessive uncertainty. Whether trading is considered halal (permissible) or haram (forbidden) depends on the nature of the trade and its adherence to these principles.

For a more in-depth exploration of the topic and specific guidelines, refer to this article: Is Forex Trading Halal or Haram? - Halal Investment Guide.

Best Forex brokers

1

9.4/10

Go to broker

eToro is a multi-asset investment platform. The value of your investments may go up or down. Your capital is at risk. Don’t invest unless you’re prepared to lose all the money you invest.

Minimum deposit:

$50, $100 (for UK clients)

Bonus for deposit:

0%

Regulation:

CySEC, FCA, ASIC

Review

The eToro broker was founded in 2007. The company promotes itself as a social trading platform working with traders from over 140 countries. The broker has several divisions operating under different jurisdictions and licensed by different regulators. For example, eToro (Europe) is licensed by the Cypriot regulator CySEC (109/10) and eToro (UK) is licensed by the British regulator FCA (583263). The broker also has a representative office in Australia and the USA. eToro Profile Details

Pros/Cons

•the minimum transaction amount for copying is $1;

•handy functionality for passive investing;

•regulated by independent monitors;

•it is possible to purchase contracts for fractional shares (that is, to invest amounts less than the cost of one share);

•it is possible to buy shares at once (not CFDs) on the US stock exchanges.

•high spreads;

•periodic technical failures in order execution;

•lack of the most popular platforms such as MetaTrader 4 and MetaTrader 5 in Europe and the CIS;

•no access to ECN systems, orders are processed only according to the STP (straight-through processing) scheme with access to specific liquidity providers;

•there is a commission for withdrawing funds;

•impolite support staff;

•inconvenient website.

Study Review

2

9.2/10

Go to broker

Your capital is at risk.

Minimum deposit:

No minimum

Bonus for deposit:

0%

Regulation:

FSC (BVI), ASIC, IIROC, FCA, CFTC, NFA

Review

The name OANDA is an acronym for “Olsen & Associates” or “Olsen AND Associates”. It is registered in the United States and provides its clients with a wide range of financial services in most countries of the world. The company was founded in 1996 and is currently regulated in four jurisdictions. The main regulator of the broker is the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Oanda Canada is licensed by IIROC. The company has several significant awards to its credit, including a victory in the category "Best Forex Trading Technologies" from the UK Forex Awards, "Best Trading Platform" from FX Week, as well as "Best Customer Service" from the US Foreign Exchange Report.

Pros/Cons

•Minimum deposit from 1 dollar.

•A large selection of the most popular trading instruments.

•Several reliable and reputable financial regulators.

•Inconvenient and poorly functioning site.

•Lack of cent accounts.

•Lack of bonus programs.

Study Review

Haram (Forbidden) things in trading

In the context of trading within Islamic finance, specific practices are identified as haram or forbidden due to their non-compliance with Sharia law. Understanding these prohibited activities is crucial for individuals aiming to align their trading practices with Islamic principles. Here are critical elements considered haram in trading:

• Riba (Excessive Interest)
  Riba refers to charging or paying interest on loans or financial instruments. Engaging in transactions involving interest is strictly forbidden in Islamic finance. This prohibition is rooted in the belief that interest creates an unjust economic system. Islamic finance provides alternative structures, such as profit-sharing models, to address this, ensuring compliance while avoiding excessive interest

• Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty)
  Gharar involves activities characterized by significant unknowns or speculation, including practices like gambling or certain derivatives trading with excessive uncertainty. Islamic finance discourages transactions with highly unpredictable outcomes, as they contradict the principles of transparency and fair dealing. The emphasis is on fostering clear and well-defined transactions that promote economic stability

• Excessive Speculation
  Engaging in high-risk, leveraged trading without a clear and informed strategy is considered haram. Islam encourages responsible and well-thought-out investment practices aligned with ethical and moral values. Traders are advised to avoid speculative activities that may lead to financial instability

• Leverage-based and Liquidation Trades
  All leverage-based trades and trades involving liquidation are considered haram in Islamic finance. Leveraged trading, involving borrowed funds to amplify positions, introduces excessive risk. Liquidation, where positions are forcibly closed to cover losses, can lead to unfair outcomes and is discouraged

If you want to try Forex trading, but are afraid of breaking the rules and laws established by Islam, open a special account for Muslims with brokers. Read more in this article: Best Forex Swap Free (Islamic) Accounts 2024

Permissible (Halal) things in trading

In trading, adherence to Halal principles involves ensuring that the company whose shares you are buying conducts completely halal dealings, including its products, investments, and overall operations.

Trading, whether in currencies, shares, or any other assets, should avoid involving leverage and liquidation.

Complete possession of currency, shares, or stocks is a prerequisite when purchasing and considering a sale. In Halal trading, possession should be evident, withdrawable, and not contingent on selling the asset again for profit.

Engaging in trading Forex, shares, or stocks without full possession is considered non-Halal. Complete possession implies that, for instance, when you buy 20 USD, those 20 USD should be visible in your account, withdrawable, and not reliant on selling to generate profit without absolute possession.

Traditionally, Forex, shares, or stock trading often entails two-step trades, allowing the sale or shorting of an asset before its purchase. This practice, resembling gharar, where trades involve excessive uncertainty, is not considered Halal for the parties involved.

Buyers and sellers should represent genuine entities rather than assumed ones to comply with Halal principles.

Halal online trading, such as over-the-counter (OTC) trades, is permissible. These trades eliminate leverage and liquidation, ensuring complete possession of assets.

Can I do online trading in Islam?

Engaging in online trading within the framework of Islamic principles involves a thoughtful examination of several key considerations.

• Intention and Purpose
  The foundation of any trading activity lies in the intention behind it. In Islamic teachings, seeking legitimate profit, supporting the economy, or fulfilling personal needs are acceptable motivations for trading. It is crucial to align one's intentions with ethical and moral values, ensuring that the pursuit of profit is within the bounds of Islamic principles

• Social Impact
  Beyond individual intentions, the broader social impact of trading choices is a significant factor. Traders are encouraged to consider how their activities contribute to positive social outcomes and to avoid practices that may cause harm to others or the environment. This encompasses a holistic perspective, emphasizing the importance of responsible and ethical trading that benefits society

• Consultation with Islamic Experts
  Given the nuanced nature of Islamic finance, seeking guidance from qualified Islamic finance experts or scholars becomes paramount. Consulting with these experts can provide personalized advice based on an individual's specific situation and the nature of their chosen trading activities. These experts can offer insights into the permissibility of particular transactions, ensuring that traders operate within the ethical boundaries set by Islamic principles