Do Forex Brokers Really Pay? Traders Union’s research

Editorial Note: While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here's an explanation for How We Make Money. None of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer.

Yes, Forex brokers do pay out money to traders. However, whether a broker pays out money reliably and efficiently depends on various factors such as their regulatory compliance, financial stability, and operational transparency. Reputable brokers are typically regulated by recognized authorities, ensuring they adhere to strict standards and practices. Additionally, traders should conduct thorough research and choose brokers with a solid reputation, positive reviews, and a track record.

At Traders Union, we understand that one of the key concerns for traders is whether Forex brokers truly pay their clients. Our team has conducted comprehensive research to address this question. As a result, we provide valuable insights into the reliability and financial practices of various Forex brokers.

Understanding Forex Brokers

For the very beginning, it’s important to understand what a Forex broker is and how they operate. Brokers act as intermediaries between traders and the market, offering platforms for executing trades, providing market data, and sometimes offering additional services such as educational resources and customer support.

Types of Forex Brokers:

Market Makers: These brokers take the opposite side of a client's trade, providing liquidity and setting bid/offer prices. They typically offer fixed spreads.

Non-Market Makers:

STP Brokers: Forward client orders directly to liquidity providers, ensuring minimal interference and markups.
ECN Brokers: Facilitate trades between participants on an electronic network, charging commissions but offering very tight spreads.

How Forex Brokers Make Money

Forex brokers, like any business, need to generate revenue to operate and provide their services. They employ several methods to earn money, each impacting traders in different ways. Here’s a breakdown of the primary revenue streams for Forex brokers:

Examples of spreads and typical commissions charged by Forex brokers:

Spreads:

EUR/USD: The spread for the EUR/USD pair can range from 0.1 pips to 3 pips, depending on the broker and market conditions. For instance:

Fixed Spread: Some brokers offer fixed spreads, such as 2 pips for EUR/USD.
Variable Spread: Variable spreads might start from as low as 0.1 pips during times of high liquidity and can widen during periods of market volatility.

GBP/USD: The spread for GBP/USD typically ranges from 0.5 pips to 4 pips.

Fixed Spread: A fixed spread for GBP/USD might be around 3 pips.
Variable Spread: Variable spreads can start from 0.5 pips and increase during less liquid periods.

Commissions:

ECN Brokers: ECN brokers usually charge a commission in addition to the spread. For example:

EUR/USD: A common commission rate is around $2.50 to $5.00 per standard lot (100,000 units) per side (opening and closing the trade), which means $5.00 to $10.00 per round turn.
GBP/USD: The commission might be similar, ranging from $2.50 to $5.00 per standard lot per side.

Overnight Financing (Swap Rates):

EUR/USD: The swap rate can vary significantly based on the broker and current interest rates. As an example:

Long Position: +0.50 pips per night.
Short Position: -1.00 pips per night.

GBP/USD: Swap rates for GBP/USD can be:

Long Position: +0.30 pips per night.
Short Position: -1.20 pips per night.

Note:

The value of the swap depends on the interest rates of central banks and is calculated for each asset separately. Swap can be negative or positive, but its basic component is the same for all. However, brokers have the right to include an additional commission into the swap, so the final values may differ significantly. The more serious the broker is, the less the swap is.

Mark-ups:

Some brokers increase the spread above the market rate to earn additional revenue. For example:

Market Rate Spread: If the market spread for EUR/USD is 0.5 pips, the broker might increase it to 1.5 pips, effectively adding a 1 pip mark-up.

Payment Processing Fees:

Fees for handling deposits and withdrawals can vary. Examples include:

Deposit Fee: Some brokers charge a fee for certain deposit methods, such as a 1% fee for credit card deposits.
Withdrawal Fee: Withdrawal fees can also vary, such as $5 per withdrawal via bank transfer.

Additional Services:

Brokers might charge for premium services such as:

Advanced Trading Tools: Subscription fees might range from $10 to $50 per month for tools like advanced charting software.
Trading Signals: Some brokers offer signal services for a monthly fee, such as $20 to $100 per month.
Market Research Reports: Access to in-depth market analysis reports might cost $30 to $100 per month.

These fees and spreads can vary widely between brokers, so it's essential to review the specific costs associated with the broker you are considering. Always refer to the broker's official website or customer support for the most accurate and up-to-date information.

So, to see how much brokers earn, refer to the examples in the table below:
	Withdrawal fee, $	Inactivity fee, $	Min Spread EUR/USD, pips	Max Spread EUR/USD, pips	ECN Spread EUR/USD (Pips)	ECN Commission	Open account
Plus500		10	0,5	0,9			Open an account Your capital is at risk.
Pepperstone			0,5	1,5	0,1	3	Open an account Your capital is at risk.
OANDA	0-15		0,1	0,5	0,15	3,5	Open an account Your capital is at risk.
FOREX.com		15	0,7	1,2	0,2	5	Study review
Interactive Brokers			0,2	0,8	0,2	2	Open an account Your capital is at risk.
IG Markets			0,6	1,2	0,8	2,3	Study review

Tips for Ensuring Payments

So, how can you ensure that the broker will pay out all your funds? Here are a few simple tips to help guarantee this.

Check Regulation and Licensing
- Verify the broker is regulated by reputable authorities such as the FCA, SEC, or ASIC.
- Look for information on the broker's website about their regulatory status and cross-check with the regulator’s official site.
Research Transparency and Security
- Review the broker’s website for detailed information on their processes, fees, and terms of service.
- Ensure the broker segregates client funds from their operational funds, which should be stated in their terms.
- Check for security measures like encryption and secure authentication processes.
Read Reviews and Case Studies
- Look for reviews from other traders
- Pay attention to both positive and negative experiences to get a balanced view.
- Consider case studies or testimonials that detail specific experiences with the broker.
Test Customer Service
- Contact the broker’s customer service with questions or issues and gauge their responsiveness and helpfulness.
- Reliable brokers typically offer multiple contact methods, including phone, email, and live chat.

For clarity, we analyzed the top 6 brokers in your region based on specific criteria.
	Regulation	Investor protection	User satisfaction score	Customer service score
Plus500	FCA, CySEC, MAS, ASIC, FMA, FSA (Seychelles)	€20,000 £85,000 SGD 75,000	5.60	5.48
Pepperstone	ASIC, FCA, DFSA, BaFin, CMA, SCB, CySec	£85,000 €20,000 €100,000 (DE)	8.40	6.98
OANDA	FSC (BVI), ASIC, IIROC, FCA, CFTC, NFA	£85,000 SGD 75,000 $500,000	6.70	5.41
FOREX.com	CIMA, FCA, FSA (Japan), NFA, IIROC, ASIC, CFTC	£85,000	8.00	5.68
Interactive Brokers	SEC, FINRA, SIPC, FCA, NSE, BSE, SEBI, SEHK, HKFE, IIROC, ASIC, CFTC, NFA	$500,000 £85,000	7.50	6.54
IG Markets	FCA, BaFin, ASIC, MAS, CySec, FINMA, BMA, CFTC, NFA	£85,000 €100,000 SGD 75,000	6.20	4.61

Red Flags to Watch Out For

To avoid potential scams, be cautious of the following red flags:

Unregulated Brokers: Always be wary of brokers that are not regulated by reputable authorities. Lack of regulation means there's no oversight, increasing the risk of fraud.
Guaranteed Profits: Be suspicious of brokers that promise guaranteed profits. Trading involves risks, and no legitimate broker can guarantee returns.
Numerous Negative Reviews: A high number of negative reviews from other traders can indicate persistent issues or unethical practices.
Unrealistic Promises: Promises of high returns with little to no risk are often too good to be true.
Lack of Transparency: Brokers who are not clear about their fees, terms, and conditions should be avoided.

Moreover, to help you avoid scam projects, we have prepared a section called "Forex Broker Blacklist". Make sure to check it out.

How Traders Make Money

We’ve covered brokers, but what forms a trader’s profit? Traders make money by buying and selling things like stocks, currencies, and commodities.

The goal is to buy at a low price and sell at a higher price to make a profit.

Some traders also earn money from dividends, which are payments from stocks, or interest from bonds. While advanced strategies can increase earnings, they also come with higher risks. Success in trading often depends on good market analysis, timing, and managing risks carefully. With the right approach, trading can be profitable, but it's important to be aware of the risks involved.

Payment Methods to Traders

When your trading operations have brought you a profit, you'll likely want to withdraw your money. It's important to pay attention to several key aspects of this procedure. Understanding withdrawal processes and payment methods will help you compare brokers, avoid unexpected costs, and ensure your money is protected. This knowledge builds trust and satisfaction with brokers, aiding traders in making better decisions, choosing the best broker, and keeping their funds safe.

Withdrawal Processes

Submitting a Request: Traders submit a withdrawal request through the broker's platform.
Processing Timeframe: The request is processed within a specified timeframe, which can vary by broker.
Possible Delays: Delays can occur due to verification requirements or banking processes. It's important for traders to be aware of these potential delays.

Payment Methods

Bank Transfers: Often used for larger sums, but may take several business days to process and may involve higher fees.
E-Wallets: These offer faster processing times and lower fees, making them a popular choice for many traders.
Credit Cards: Convenient for quick transactions, but can come with higher fees and potential interest charges.

	Withdrawal Method	Withdrawal fee, $
Plus500	Visa, Mastercard, e-wallets (Skrill, PayPal, and others), bank transfer
Pepperstone	Visa, Mastercard, bank accounts, PayPal, Neteller, Skrill, BPay, Union Pay, EMPESA
OANDA	Visa, Mastercard, Skrill, Neteller and various Alternate Payment Methods	0-15
FOREX.com	Bank transfer, payment cards
Interactive Brokers	Bank Transfer (SEPA), US ACH Transfer, Direct Debit/Electronic Clearinghouse (ACH), Cheque, Canadian ETF Transfer, BACS / GIRO / ACH
IG Markets	Visa, Mastercard, and bank transfers

Expert opinion

I can confirm that reputable Forex brokers do indeed pay out money to traders. However, the reliability and efficiency of these payments depend on several factors, including the broker's regulatory compliance, financial stability, and operational transparency. Brokers regulated by recognized authorities such as the FCA, SEC, or ASIC are required to adhere to strict standards and practices, which enhances their reliability.

It's crucial for traders to conduct thorough research before choosing a broker. This includes reading reviews, checking regulatory status, and understanding the broker's fee structure and withdrawal processes. Reputable brokers typically have positive reviews and a solid track record of customer satisfaction.

However, traders should be wary of brokers with numerous negative reviews, lack of regulation, or unrealistic profit promises. These are often red flags for potential scams. By selecting well-regulated and positively reviewed brokers, traders can significantly reduce risks and ensure they receive their funds reliably.

Conclusion

In conclusion, reputable Forex brokers do pay out funds as expected. However, it is essential to conduct thorough research, read user reviews, understand withdrawal processes, and ensure the broker is well-regulated. By following these steps, you can significantly reduce the risk of encountering issues when withdrawing your profits.

FAQs

How do brokers make money?

Brokers earn through spreads, commissions, overnight financing, and additional service fees.

What are typical fees and commissions?

Fees vary but usually include spreads (fixed or variable), per-trade commissions, and possibly payment processing fees.

How to avoid scam brokers?

Choose regulated brokers, read reviews, verify credentials, and avoid those with unrealistic promises.

What to do if a broker doesn't pay out?

If a broker fails to pay out, contact their customer service immediately, file a complaint with the relevant regulatory authority, and consider seeking legal advice to resolve the issue.

Team that worked on the article

Igor is an experienced finance professional with expertise across various domains, including banking, financial analysis, trading, marketing, and business development. Over the course of his career spanning more than 18 years, he has acquired a diverse skill set that encompasses a wide range of responsibilities. As an author at Traders Union, he leverages his extensive knowledge and experience to create valuable content for the trading community.

Learn about our editorial policies

Dr. BJ Johnson is a PhD in English Language and an editor with over 15 years of experience. He earned his degree in English Language in the U.S and the UK. In 2020, Dr. Johnson joined the Traders Union team. Since then, he has created over 100 exclusive articles and edited over 300 articles of other authors.

Mirjan Hipolito is a journalist and news editor at Traders Union. She is an expert crypto writer with five years of experience in the financial markets. Her specialties are daily market news, price predictions, and Initial Coin Offerings (ICO).

Forex Trading

Forex trading, short for foreign exchange trading, is the practice of buying and selling currencies in the global foreign exchange market with the aim of profiting from fluctuations in exchange rates. Traders speculate on whether one currency will rise or fall in value relative to another currency and make trading decisions accordingly. However, beware that trading carries risks, and you can lose your whole capital.

Long position

A long position in Forex, represents a positive outlook on the future value of a currency pair. When a trader assumes a long position, they are essentially placing a bet that the base currency in the pair will appreciate in value compared to the quote currency.

Cryptocurrency

Cryptocurrency is a type of digital or virtual currency that relies on cryptography for security. Unlike traditional currencies issued by governments (fiat currencies), cryptocurrencies operate on decentralized networks, typically based on blockchain technology.

Investor

An investor is an individual, who invests money in an asset with the expectation that its value would appreciate in the future. The asset can be anything, including a bond, debenture, mutual fund, equity, gold, silver, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and real-estate property.

Volatility

Volatility refers to the degree of variation or fluctuation in the price or value of a financial asset, such as stocks, bonds, or cryptocurrencies, over a period of time. Higher volatility indicates that an asset's price is experiencing more significant and rapid price swings, while lower volatility suggests relatively stable and gradual price movements.

Top 5 companies for you