Are Binary Options Halal or Haram? Binary Trading in Islam
Whether binary options are halal depends on individual interpretation, but scholars generally lean toward viewing them as haram.
For Muslims interested in binary options trading, a pivotal question arises: are they halal or haram according to Islamic law? This issue is debated among scholars as binary options involve predicting price movements within a set time. On one hand, some argue this makes it a form of gambling since the outcome is based on chance. However, others state that with research and analysis rather than relying on luck, binary options can be traded similar to regular investments. This article discusses both perspectives on binary options and Sharia law. It provides clarity on the debate while also offering alternatives for Muslims who wish to trade within their religious principles.
Start trading Binary Options now with Pocket Options!Key points from the article
-
Some scholars assert that binary options fall under the category of gambling, since the outcome depends on predicting market fluctuations outside of one's control, akin to betting.
-
Proponents of its permissibility argue that binary options have potential to involve studying market trends and employing analytical strategies, bearing similarity to accepted practices like conventional investing which incorporate expertise rather than mere fortune.
-
Even if binary options are halal, some Muslim-majority countries have banned or issued warnings against them due to risks.
-
Alternatives for Muslims include Islamic forex trading without interest, CFD trading without expiry dates, and long-term stock investing.
-
Scholars have tended to conclude that binary options clash with prohibitions.
Are Binary Options Halal or Haram?
The Islamic faith is based on the belief that there is only one God, and that Muhammad is his last prophet. Muslims are required to follow the teachings of the Quran and the Sunnah (the Prophetic tradition). One of the main principles of Islam is that everything is permissible unless it's specifically prohibited by Allah.
There are two types of things that are prohibited in Islam: those that are haram and those that are makruh. Haram means "forbidden" while makruh means "disliked". Something that is haram is completely off-limits, while something that is makruh should be avoided if possible.
Now that we've established that, let's take a look at binary options trading and see where it falls on the spectrum. But first, what is binary options trading?
Best Binary Options BrokersBinary Options Trading
Binary options trading is a type of financial trading that involves predicting the direction of an asset's price movement and investing accordingly. If your prediction is correct, you will make a profit. If it's not, you will lose your investment.
Binary options are different from other types of financial instruments, such as stocks and bonds, because they only have two possible outcomes: you either make a profit or lose your investment. There is no middle ground. This makes binary options trading a high-risk, high-reward type of investment. And because of this, some people believe that it is haram.
The Argument For Binary Options Trading Being Haram
Those who believe that binary options trading is haram are usually of the opinion that all forms of gambling are forbidden by Islam. They argue that since there is an element of chance involved in binary options trading, it falls under the category of gambling. And since gambling is haram, binary options trading must also be haram.
Another argument that is often made is that you are essentially betting on the direction of an asset's price movement. And since Islam prohibits speculation, this makes binary options trading haram as well.
Best Binary Options Trading StrategyThe Argument for Binary Options Trading Being Halal
On the other side of the argument are those who believe that binary options trading is halal. These are their core points:
The skill argument: Binary proponents argue that binary options trading isn't gambling because there's a level of skill involved in predicting the direction of an asset's price movement.
The prediction argument: This argument claims that traders aren't actually betting on the direction of an asset's price movement.
Rather, you are investing based on your prediction, and it's therefore not a form of gambling. This means your prediction isn't the product of chance, but a calculated and weighted prognosis, requiring considerable effort.
The investment argument: This argument asserts that binary options trading is a type of investment and not speculation because you are not buying the asset itself, but rather a contract that will pay out if your prediction is correct.
Binary Options Trading as Usury
Another argument that is sometimes made is that binary options trading is a form of usury and therefore haram. Usury describes the practice of lending money with interest, and it's prohibited in Islam.
The argument goes that since you are essentially "betting" on the direction of an asset's price movement, and if your prediction is correct, you'll make a profit, then binary options trading is a form of usury.
The argument that binary trading is usury is fundamentally flawed. That's because, in binary options trading, you aren't actually lending money. You're investing your own money, and if your prediction is correct, you'll make a profit. If it's not, you'll lose your investment. There's no interest involved.
TOP-10 Best Binary Option Indicators For BeginnersIs Binary Trading Legal in Muslim Countries?
While binary trading is legal in countries like the United States and the United Kingdom, it may not be legal in Muslim countries. This is especially true considering how Muslims are strong adherents to their faith and doctrines.
That said, here are a few Muslim countries and their binary options legal statuses:
Indonesia: Sharia Law prohibits Muslims from earning interest, so binary trading is not allowed.
Malaysia: The Malaysian government has issued a fatwa against binary options trading, but it's not legally binding.
Pakistan: Binary trading is legal in Pakistan, but only if you trade through a foreign broker.
Turkey: Turkey has banned all forms of gambling. The country categorizes binary options trading as gambling, making it legal.
Saudi Arabia: Saudi Arabia has no specific laws or regulations in place regarding binary options trading.
UAE: The UAE has issued a warning against binary options trading, but it's not legally binding.
Binary Options Alternatives
If trading binary options is illegal in your country. You can either quit trading for good or explore binary options trading alternatives. Some of these options include:
Islamic forex trading: You can trade foreign currencies without the possibility of interest.
CFD trading: You can trade contracts for difference, which are similar to binary options but don't have a fixed expiry date.
Spread betting: Spread betting is only available in certain countries, and it allows you to bet on the price movement of an asset without actually owning it.
Investing in stocks: You can buy stocks and hold them for the long term. This isn't gambling, but an investment form that's likely to pay off.
Is Investing in Stocks Haram or Halal?As you can see, there are a number of options available to Muslim traders who want to trade binary options. It's important to do your research and make sure you are comfortable with the option you choose. And, as always, consult with a financial advisor to get professional advice.
You'll have to check with local authorities to confirm whether trading the said assets is actually legal. If not, you can always try to find a broker that's located in a country where binary trading is legal.
Best Islamic Trading Accounts for 2024
Unlike traditional trading accounts, Islamic trading accounts have a few special features to accommodate Muslims who want to trade in accordance with their faith. Here are a few things you can expect from an Islamic trading account:
No interest charged on trades
No fees for overnight positions
Swap-free options are available
Account management in accordance with Sharia Law principles
With that out of the way, let's look at the best trading accounts for Muslims.
RoboForex Islamic Account
RoboForex offers forex and CFD trading on various asset classes, including forex, metals, energies, indices, and cryptocurrencies.
One of the main attractions of RoboForex is that they offer swap-free accounts. This account type is available to all traders, not just Muslim traders.
RoboForex offers leverage of up to 1:2000 on their swap-free accounts, which is one of the highest in the industry. However, please note that leverage can also increase your losses, so use it carefully.
XM Islamic Account
This forex account type is offered by XM, a forex brokerage firm that is based in Cyprus.
As the name suggests, the XM Islamic account is a forex account that is designed for Muslim traders. This account type is compliant with Sharia law as it does not charge or earn any swap or interest.
To open an XM Islamic account, simply register for a live account on the XM website and select Islamic account as your account type. You will then need to deposit a minimum of $5 into your account to start trading.
XM offers leverage of up to 1:888 on this account type, which means that you can control a large amount of money with a relatively small deposit. However, please note that leverage can also increase your losses, so use it carefully.
This account type allows you to trade forex, CFDs, metals, and energies. So you have a wide range of markets to choose from.
Overall, the XM Islamic account is a good choice for Muslim traders who are looking for a forex account that is compliant with Sharia law. This account type has no swap or interest charges, a low minimum deposit, and high leverage. XM is not regulated by a major financial regulator such as the US SEC or UK FCA.
Summary
Are binary options halal? That depends on your interpretation of Sharia Law, but it mostly tilts towards the haram. But just because trading binary options isn't halal, you don't have to give up on trading completely.
There are several ways for Muslim traders to trade binary options and other assets without violating their religious beliefs. And, there are even brokerages that offer Islamic account options that are in compliance with Sharia Law. So, if you're a Muslim trader who wants to trade binary options, there are a number of options available to you.
Do your research and consult with a financial advisor to find the best way for you to trade binary options without violating your religious beliefs. And, always remember to check with local authorities to confirm whether trading binary options is actually legal in your country.
Related Articles
Team that worked on the article
Alamin Morshed is a contributor at Traders Union. He specializes in writing articles for businesses who want to improve their Google search rankings to compete with their competition.
Over the past four years, Alamin has been working independently and through online employment platforms such as Upwork and Fiverr, and also contributing to some reputable blogs. His goal is to balance informative content and provide an entertaining read to his readers.
His motto is: I can dream or I can do—I choose action.
Olga Shendetskaya has been a part of the Traders Union team as an author, editor and proofreader since 2017. Since 2020, Shendetskaya has been the assistant chief editor of the website of Traders Union, an international association of traders. She has over 10 years of experience of working with economic and financial texts. In the period of 2017-2020, Olga has worked as a journalist and editor of laftNews news agency, economic and financial news sections. At the moment, Olga is a part of the team of top industry experts involved in creation of educational articles in finance and investment, overseeing their writing and publication on the Traders Union website.
Olga has extensive experience in writing and editing articles about the specifics of working in the Forex market, cryptocurrency market, stock exchanges and also in the segment of financial investment in general. This level of expertise allows Olga to create unique and comprehensive articles, describing complex investment mechanisms in a simple and accessible way for traders of any level.
Olga’s motto: Do well and you’ll be well!
Mirjan Hipolito is a journalist and news editor at Traders Union. She is an expert crypto writer with five years of experience in the financial markets. Her specialties are daily market news, price predictions, and Initial Coin Offerings (ICO). Mirjan is a cryptocurrency and stock trader. This deep understanding of the finance sector allows her to create informative and engaging content that helps readers easily navigate the complexities of the crypto world.