Global markets safe-haven strains challenge portfolio defenses

Global markets safe-haven strains challenge portfolio defenses
Safe-haven assets tested

Market swings this month are highlighting how traditional defensive assets can fail to protect investors when inflation, fiscal concerns and liquidity stress drive the selloff. Treasuries, gold and major haven currencies still play key roles in portfolio construction, but strategists and academics say their reliability is becoming more conditional.

Highlights

  • Long-dated U.S. Treasuries declined alongside equities in April 2025 as inflation, fiscal risks, and market liquidity concerns drove 10-year yields sharply higher.
  • Gold broke technical support and hit a one-year low in late October, demonstrating vulnerability to margin calls and liquidity needs during market shocks.
  • The diversification value of U.S. Treasuries is weakening due to $40 trillion in debt, $2 trillion annual deficits, and $1.1 trillion in annual interest costs, making bonds and stocks increasingly correlated.

How bonds, gold and currencies are behaving

As reported by Reuters, recent market shocks are testing the assets investors usually buy when risk appetite collapses. In April 2025, fears over U.S. tariffs trigger an equity selloff, but long-dated Treasuries decline alongside stocks as investors worry about inflation, fiscal risks and market liquidity, pushing 10-year yields sharply higher.

A similar pattern emerges after the start of the U.S.-Israeli war with Iran on February 28, when oil jumps and bond yields rise on expectations that inflation will increase. That undermines the usual role of Treasuries as a cushion in risk-off periods, especially when the market focus shifts from recession risk to price pressures and Federal Reserve tightening.

Gold is also proving less predictable in the short term. It falls with stocks in late October, breaks technical support and touches a one-year low, reinforcing the view that the metal can come under pressure when investors need liquidity or face margin calls.

Steve Englander, global head of G10 FX research and head of North America macro strategy at Standard Chartered Bank, says positioning can matter as much as fundamentals after a market shock. In that environment, the strongest haven may simply be the asset investors were short and must buy back quickly.

Campbell Harvey, a finance professor at Duke University's Fuqua School of Business, calls U.S. Treasuries the world's benchmark safe asset, but says their diversification value is weakening as stocks and bonds increasingly move in the same direction. He also points to the scale of U.S. borrowing, including $40 trillion in debt, annual deficits of about $2 trillion and interest payments of $1.1 trillion, as factors adding risk to Treasuries.

Harvey says gold remains more dependable over extremely long holding periods than over short ones. With annualized volatility above 15%, near the S&P 500's level, and only a loose average correlation with equities over multi-year windows, gold can still fall during episodes when inflation surprises hurt both stocks and bonds.

As a reminder, our earlier coverage on family office alternatives described wealthy investors boosting private markets and hedge funds amid inflation and volatility.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.