Cardano treasury proposal to buy copper fails after holders reject 22 million ADA request

Cardano treasury proposal to buy copper fails after holders reject 22 million ADA request
Cardano copper bid rejected

Cardano token holders have voted down a proposal to use about $5 million from the network's treasury to buy physical copper, blocking an unusual attempt to deploy communal crypto funds into a real-world commodity. The result also preserves scarce treasury capacity under Cardano's withdrawal cap through about July 2027, because the request would have used more than half of the uncommitted amount.

Highlights

  • Cardano holders overwhelmingly rejected Toto Finance's 22 million ADA treasury proposal, with over 2.86 billion ADA voted against and only 20 million ADA in favor.
  • Toto Finance's requested 22 million ADA would have used two-thirds for buying COMEX-grade copper, consuming over half the remaining treasury withdrawal cap of 500 million ADA.
  • The proposal faced economic concerns as copper needed a 49% price increase for ADA value recovery, while Toto could have earned up to 3.36 million ADA in fees.

Voting result and proposal structure

As reported by CoinDesk, stake voting against the proposal exceeded support by more than 140 to 1 when the ballot closed Sunday, with delegated representatives casting just over 20 million ADA in favor and 2.86 billion ADA against it, according to the onchain record on Cardanocube. Another 131 million ADA voted no-confidence, while the measure secured less than 1% of the stake that chose a side.

Toto Finance, which issues blockchain tokens backed by commodities, had requested 22 million ADA from Cardano's treasury. About two-thirds of the funds would have been used to buy COMEX-grade copper stored near New Orleans, with the metal tokenized at one token per pound, held for 18 to 24 months and sold later, with proceeds scheduled to return to the treasury by month 36.

Treasury withdrawals require yes votes from 67% of the active voting stake. The constitutional committee, a seven-member body that reviews whether spending requests comply with Cardano's constitution, also provided no support, with three members voting no and four not voting.

Treasury constraints and market implications

The failed measure leaves additional room under Cardano's treasury spending limit. Holders capped withdrawals at 500 million ADA through about July 2027, and 457.4 million ADA of that total had already been committed as of Oct. 16, meaning Toto Finance's request alone would have consumed more than half of the remaining capacity.

The proposal had also faced questions over economic risk. Copper would have needed to rise about 49% for the treasury to recover its ADA value if ADA's dollar price stayed flat, while Toto stood to collect up to about 3.36 million ADA, roughly 15% of the request, through technology and management fees, an execution fee and a margin on storage and insurance invoices.

Founder Monty Metzger told CoinDesk in October that "Toto takes no profit from this proposal." Toto Finance had not answered questions sent last week, including whether it plans to resubmit the request, by publication time.

As we noted earlier, ETF outflows helped drive a historic crypto market selloff alongside heavy Bitcoin and Ethereum liquidations.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.