Capita-run civil service pension delays risk tax costs for bereaved families
Administrative delays in the civil service pension scheme are raising the risk that bereaved families lose access to tax-free lump sum death benefits. More than 1,600 claims linked to deceased civil servants have been waiting for over 100 days, increasing pressure on ministers to change the rules or speed up payments.
Highlights
- Delays in Capita-run civil service pension payments may cause death benefit claims to exceed the two-year tax-free window, exposing bereaved families to additional tax.
- The Cabinet Office is withholding nearly £10 million from Capita due to ongoing service delays affecting the 1.7 million-member scheme and increasing scrutiny from MPs and unions.
- Public accounts committee urges legislative change as complainants face 18-month Pensions Ombudsman wait and ministers maintain payouts are subject to existing HMRC tax rules on delays.
Processing delays and tax exposure
As first reported by The Guardian, MPs are warning that prolonged disruption in the Capita-run civil service pension scheme could push some death benefit payments beyond the two-year window required for tax-free treatment under HM Revenue and Customs rules.Under those rules, when a member dies before the age of 75, a lump sum payment is only tax-free if it is made within two years of the scheme being notified of the death. If that deadline is missed, the payment is taxed at the recipient's marginal rate, creating a potential financial hit for families already affected by bereavement.
Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, chair of the Commons public accounts committee, says the current disruption means the chances of payments being made within that timeframe are slim. He describes the prospect of families facing extra tax because of administrative failings as unjust and unconscionable.
The Cabinet Office, which is responsible for the scheme, says it cannot prevent HMRC from applying tax to delayed claims. It adds that affected members would need to seek redress through the Pensions Ombudsman, which estimates that cases currently take about 18 months to resolve because of the volume of complaints.
Pressure on government and contractor
The public accounts committee is calling for legislative change so relatives do not bear the cost of delays caused by scheme administration. The issue adds to wider criticism of the government's repeated outsourcing of the 1.7 million-member civil service pension scheme after earlier concerns over deteriorating service levels.The committee last year urged ministers to bring the scheme in-house after previous contractor MyCSP was blamed for weaker performance. Even so, a £239 million contract was awarded to Capita last December despite concerns that the company might not be adequately prepared, and the Cabinet Office has since acknowledged that service levels are unacceptable.
In February, a dedicated email address was created for unions to escalate severe hardship cases caused by the delays, including claimants said to be at risk of suicide or losing their homes. One claimant, Clare Norris, says she has been waiting 11 months for death benefit and pension payments due after her husband's death last November.
Capita says her case will move forward under a new process and remains a high priority. The Cabinet Office says it is continuing to hold back nearly £10 million in payments to Capita while trying to ensure members do not suffer delays, and maintains that complaint routes can provide compensation or financial redress where tax charges arise.
Our earlier coverage of Pakistan’s Tax Year 2026 income tax return deadline explained how tax experts and business groups urged the Federal Board of Revenue to grant more time after the final return form notification and ongoing technical problems on the IRIS portal. The report highlighted concerns that taxpayers could face compliance risks and potential penalties due to system glitches and unresolved extension requests.