Puerto Rico chiropractor sentenced in tax shelter fraud case
A federal tax fraud case tied to an abusive shelter scheme is resulting in prison time for a Puerto Rico chiropractor and former healthcare executive. The sentence includes 15 months in prison, one year of supervised release, and more than $1.7 million in restitution and interest tied to concealed income exceeding $4.1 million.
Highlights
- Stuart Bernsen was sentenced for filing a false tax return tied to an illegal tax shelter used from 2019 to 2021, after pleading guilty.
- Bernsen concealed more than $4.1 million in income through abusive trusts and a fraudulent charitable foundation, causing a tax loss of over $1.2 million.
- The court ordered Bernsen to pay $1,295,663 in restitution plus $429,026 in interest and sentenced him to one year of supervised release.
Court findings and sentence terms
As reported by the U.S. Department of Justice, Stuart Bernsen was sentenced last week for filing a false tax return connected to an illegal tax shelter that he used from 2019 through 2021. Bernsen, who previously lived in Westmont, Illinois, had already pleaded guilty under a plea agreement.According to court documents and statements made in court, Bernsen was the former CEO and co-founder of a company that managed more than 100 chiropractic clinics across the U.S. Prosecutors said the shelter used abusive trusts and a fraudulent charitable foundation to conceal more than $4.1 million in income, causing a tax loss of more than $1.2 million.
The court also ordered Bernsen to pay restitution of $1,295,663 and interest of $429,026. He was additionally sentenced to one year of supervised release.
How the scheme worked and enforcement focus
Authorities said Bernsen paid about $25,000 to establish the shelter despite warnings from a tax professional and IRS guidance that the arrangement was improper. The structure was designed to make it appear that he had permanently transferred control of business interests, including his chiropractic business, to trusts or a foundation, while he in fact continued to control the assets and benefit from their income.Prosecutors said Bernsen diverted income to the trust, used it for personal spending, and falsely claimed those costs as deductible trust administration expenses. The spending included his children's college tuition, a diamond worth more than $60,000, a boat, real estate, and the rental of a luxury villa in St. Barth's through the purported charitable foundation for himself and his family.
IRS Criminal Investigation investigated the case, and Assistant Deputy Chief Boris Bourget of the National Fraud Enforcement Division's Tax Section prosecuted it. Assistant Attorney General Colin M. McDonald and U.S. Attorney Andrew S. Boutros announced the outcome, as the Justice Department says its Fraud Division is focusing on fraud cases affecting the American public.
We have also discussed the broader context around a court order imposing a permanent injunction on a San Diego tax preparer.