U.S. bankruptcy examiner selections face scrutiny over DoJ political influence fears
Concerns are rising in the U.S. corporate bankruptcy market over whether politics is starting to shape the selection of Chapter 11 examiners. The debate centers on the Department of Justice's oversight of the U.S. Trustee program after recent appointments in major cases, including Hughes Satellite Systems and First Brands.
Highlights
- Senior bankruptcy lawyers report increased Department of Justice involvement in examiner selections, curbing the Office of the U.S. Trustee's traditional autonomy.
- Recent appointments of Steven Engel for Hughes Satellite Systems and Martin De Luca for First Brands draw scrutiny due to their political ties and limited bankruptcy experience.
- Tara Twomey's March 2025 dismissal and alleged politicisation raise industry fears that examiner positions may reward political loyalists with multimillion-dollar Chapter 11 assignments.
Recent appointments intensify oversight concerns
As reported by Financial Times, several senior bankruptcy lawyers say the Department of Justice is taking a bigger role in choosing examiner candidates, reducing the traditional autonomy of the Office of the U.S. Trustee, which represents the public interest in bankruptcy proceedings.That concern is drawing attention to the recent appointment of Steven Engel to investigate events leading to the Chapter 11 filing by Hughes Satellite Systems in August. Engel is a prominent lawyer whose background includes senior service in the first Trump administration, and one person familiar with the process says the main DoJ made its preference for him clear, although a person close to a Hughes creditor group says creditors are satisfied with his trial and investigative experience.
The issue has also been sharpened by the selection of Martin De Luca as examiner in the First Brands bankruptcy, a case involving billions of dollars of alleged fraud linked to the autoparts maker's founder. Lawyers and advisers involved in that case say they are puzzled by the choice because of De Luca's comparatively limited direct experience in major U.S. bankruptcy matters, while noting his ties to Trump-related legal and political circles.
Industry response and implications for Chapter 11 work
The unease follows the March 2025 dismissal of Tara Twomey, who was appointed director of the U.S. Trustee program in 2023 and is now seeking reinstatement while citing civil service protections. Lawyers in the sector say the change has raised questions about whether examiner appointments risk becoming a way to reward Trump and Republican loyalists with prestigious assignments that can generate millions of dollars in fees, rather than a means of influencing the substance of examiner findings.One senior New York lawyer says examiner selection had never been political before this administration, while another large law firm executive says his firm has begun looking for Trump connections that could help it win future roles as counsel to examiners. A lawyer who has previously served as a bankruptcy examiner also says he no longer plans to seek such appointments during the Trump administration because of his past Democratic Party ties.
The DoJ rejects the criticism, saying bankruptcy courts must approve examiners proposed by the U.S. Trustee and that suggestions of politicisation are false. Boies Schiller Flexner also defends De Luca's appointment, saying the firm was selected through a competitive process in consultation with relevant private stakeholders and that the court reviewed and approved the choice.
We recently wrote about UK regulators expanding supervision through the critical third party regime covering firms like BlackRock and Bloomberg.