Congressional Democrats probe DOJ role in OpenAI copyright case
Congressional Democrats are escalating scrutiny of the Justice Department over its intervention in a high-profile copyright lawsuit involving OpenAI and Microsoft. The effort centers on whether the department coordinated its position without key agency input and whether outside companies influenced its filing.
Highlights
- House Democrats, led by Rep. Chellie Pingree, are questioning the DOJ's support for OpenAI and Microsoft in the New York Times copyright case.
- The lawmakers criticize the DOJ for filing its Sept. 1 statement of interest without consulting the U.S. Copyright Office or the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
- The absence of career antitrust attorneys' signatures and requests for documentation highlight concerns about DOJ bias and potential for broader federal investigations.
Lawmakers seek records on DOJ filing process
As first reported by Axios, a group of House Democrats is circulating a letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche this week that questions whether the Justice Department showed bias when it backed AI companies in the New York Times' copyright infringement case against OpenAI and Microsoft.The letter is being circulated by Rep. Chellie Pingree of Maine and is also signed by Reps. Becca Balint of Vermont, Deborah Ross of North Carolina, Raja Krishnamoorthi of Illinois, and California lawmakers Judy Chu, Jared Huffman and Ro Khanna. The lawmakers say they are alarmed that the U.S. Copyright Office and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office were not consulted before the DOJ's Sept. 1 statement of interest, and they question why the department intervened after the Trump administration had previously supported letting courts decide whether training AI on copyrighted material qualifies as fair use.
The lawmakers argue that the DOJ's intervention, combined with the lack of consultation with key agencies, raises serious questions about possible bias. They are asking the department to turn over draft statements and other documents tied to the filing, and to identify any external companies or organizations that supplied legal analysis, briefing materials or other communications related to it. The Justice Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Copyright dispute adds to broader oversight push
Statements of interest are meant to reflect the official position of the entire U.S. government in private litigation. While they are not binding on courts, they can carry significant influence in major cases and help shape judicial thinking on contested legal issues.The Democrats also point to the absence of career antitrust attorneys' signatures on the September filing alongside senior DOJ officials, describing that as unusual. They contend the statement of interest could undermine public trust in the department's impartiality and its ability to represent the nation's broader interests in a closely watched dispute over AI training and copyrighted content.
The letter has not drawn Republican support so far and arrives as Democrats prepare to take majority control of Congress, setting up a wider round of investigations into alleged bias and corruption across the federal government. The lawmakers are seeking answers on the DOJ's process by the end of the month, saying artists and creators need confidence that proper procedures were followed.