Google faces new regulatory risk as YouTube scrutiny intensifies

Google faces new regulatory risk as YouTube scrutiny intensifies
Google

​GOOGL is trading around $344 on August 26, attempting to hold onto gains from recent sessions, but a new regulatory factor has now been added to the already known concerns surrounding returns on AI investment. Today, Meta agreed to settle a major case brought by U.S. authorities over the alleged harm of social media to children and teenagers.

Initially, Meta shares rose by around 4% as legal uncertainty eased, but it later emerged that the maximum settlement amount could reach about $16.7 billion and will affect the company’s near-term financial results. For Alphabet, this case is important as a potential benchmark for the cost of similar litigation, since YouTube is also involved in a broad wave of lawsuits over the impact of social platforms on minors.

Meta settlement raises benchmark for YouTube risk

The risk for Google is not purely theoretical. In March, a California jury already found Google and Meta liable in one of the landmark cases, with Google found negligent in the design or operation of YouTube and responsible for 30% of the damages awarded in that case. In June, YouTube separately settled another lawsuit involving a minor on confidential terms, while thousands of similar cases against major social platforms are still ongoing.

Therefore, today’s Meta settlement could force the market to assess more carefully Alphabet’s potential future payouts and, more importantly, the risk of tighter restrictions on YouTube, including age verification, time limits, and other measures that could affect engagement and advertising monetization.

Strong operating results provide cushion

At the same time, Alphabet’s operating results still provide the company with a significant cushion. In the second quarter, revenue rose by 24% y/y to $119.8 billion, Google Search & other increased by 17%, YouTube advertising by 13%, while Google Cloud accelerated by as much as 82% to $24.8 billion. Alphabet’s operating margin expanded to 34%, while Cloud continues to become a more important source of profit.

This is why the regulatory risk surrounding YouTube does not yet change the fundamental investment thesis, but it could reduce the valuation premium, especially if future settlements run into billions of dollars or require changes that limit advertising inventory.

Inflation keeps pressure on valuation

Today’s macroeconomic data also provide no clear support for GOOGL. Headline PCE remained at 3.7% y/y, while core PCE held at 3.3%, so the probability of Fed rates staying high for longer remains significant. For Alphabet, this is negative through the discount rate, although weak GDP growth of 1.5% annualized partly limits the potential for a further rise in yields.

The inability of bulls to break through resistance around $352 points to continued risks of a break below support near $340, in which case a decline toward $332-324 should be expected. A confident breakout above the resistance mentioned above, as I noted in the article Google shifts toward enterprise AI monetization as shares stabilize, would lead to a move toward $360.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.