Victoria home auctions track close to published reserve prices in early law-change data

Victoria home auctions track close to published reserve prices in early law-change data
Home auction prices align

Victoria's new requirement to publish auction reserve prices a week in advance is showing early signs of narrowing the gap between advertised expectations and final sale outcomes. Data covering 2,164 residential auctions between October 16 and November 14 indicates homes sold at auction for a median of 0.9 percent above the published reserve price.

Highlights

  • Victorian auction data from Homer shows properties sold at a median of 0.9 percent above the published reserve price in the rule's first month.
  • More than 75 percent of sold homes had a reserve price within the quoted price guide range, increasing pricing transparency and buyer alignment.
  • Despite concerns of a market shift to private sales, early figures indicate new reserve-disclosure laws are helping match advertised, reserve, and sale prices in a cooler market.

Early results from Victoria's auction rule

As reported by ABC News, early analysis compiled by property platform Homer suggests the state's reserve-price disclosure law is improving pricing transparency in residential auctions. The dataset covers the first month since the rule took effect for sales from October 16, and shows buyers and sellers are transacting close to the price publicly signalled before auction day.

Under the change, sellers must publish the reserve price, the minimum they are willing to accept, one week before an auction. Sellers were already required to provide a price guide range of no more than 10 percent, and the new figures show more than three-quarters of sold homes had a reserve within that advertised range.

Homer chief executive Henry Pedersen said properties sold at auction for a median of 0.9 percent above the published reserve, indicating advertised pricing is aligning more closely with final outcomes. He also said homes with reserves above the guide were passed in more often, at 50 percent, compared with 41 percent for homes where the reserve sat within the quoted range.

Independent property economist Cameron Kusher said the initial figures are encouraging, but warned that five weeks of data in a weaker market are not enough for firm conclusions. He said a reserve price set within or below the guide range is more likely to support a successful result at auction.

Market pressure shapes wider policy debate

The Victorian shift is drawing attention across Australia as policymakers look for ways to curb underquoting, a practice that leaves buyers pursuing homes priced below what sellers or agents realistically expect. The issue carries financial and time costs for buyers who pay for inspections and reports on properties that may never have been attainable at the advertised level.

The debate is unfolding as the housing market cools and some sellers lower their expectations. In NSW, the government has scrapped underquoting reforms that barred agents from advertising below a rejected written offer, with Premier Chris Minns saying falling prices make such rules harder to apply when values no longer move in one direction.

Victoria faces similar market conditions, and agents had expected some sellers to shift toward private sales, which do not require publication of a reserve price. Even so, the first month of results suggests the new auction framework is helping align advertised ranges, reserves and sale prices more closely in a softer market.

As we noted earlier, Metro Manila repricing pressure is building as higher yields push non-prime owners to cut asking prices.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.