Genting Group halts Sycal’s Sky City project in Genting Highlands
A development dispute near First World Hotel in Genting Highlands has gone in Genting Group’s favour after the court granted preventive relief against work alleged to pose risks to the slope and resort access. The decision also resulted in damages, legal costs and an order to restore the slope, while part of the judgment is under appeal at the Court of Appeal.
Highlights
- The High Court granted an injunction on 30 April to stop Sycal Bhd from building its Sky City hotel and commercial project in Genting Highlands.
- The judge ordered Sycal to pay RM2 million in costs and RM243,800 in general damages, and to restore the slope damaged in connection with the unlawful project.
- The ruling bars Sycal from carrying out further work, while the appeal remains pending at the Court of Appeal after a six-year trial spanning 76 days.
This article was translated from the original. Read the original version by our correspondent here.
Court ruling and scope of the project
As reported by The Edge Malaysia, on 30 April the High Court granted a quia timet injunction to Genting Highlands Bhd, Genting Malaysia Bhd and First World Hotels and Resorts Sdn Bhd to prevent Sycal Bhd from carrying out its proposed construction of a hotel and commercial buildings on a lot adjacent to their resort in Genting Highlands.The plaintiffs argued that the development could affect the structure of First World Hotel and the road leading to the resort. Genting sought the order to protect existing properties owned by First World Hotels and Resorts, including the hotel, Sky Avenue, Arena of Stars, Genting International Convention Centre and indoor theme park.
High Court Judge Datuk Aliza Sulaiman, now a Court of Appeal judge, also ordered the defendants to pay RM2 million in costs and RM243,800 in general damages for slope damage at the highland resort linked to the project proposed by Sycal and its subsidiary. The court also declared the earthworks and slope modifications unlawful in the absence of valid approval, ordered the restoration of certain slope supports and restrained any further unlawful work.
According to the case, GM Aero Support Sdn Bhd and Sycal planned to build 10 blocks on their land northeast of First World Hotel, comprising a hotel, 27- to 56-storey commercial suites and parking facilities. The defendants had submitted the project proposal to the Bentong Municipal Council, the local planning authority.
Implications for resort operations and the appeal process
Genting alleged that the development, located about 100 metres from First World Hotel, could affect slope stability and cause a nuisance and trespass, as well as give rise to negligence claims relating to earthworks and allegedly unlawful slope cutting. The company had also previously sent a letter to GM Aero stating that the work being carried out posed a serious threat to the safety and stability of the hotel, surrounding land, roads and other properties.The dispute began with legal proceedings filed in February 2020 against GM Aero, Sycal, Lau Yee Sum (Consulting Engineer), Perunding Rekacekap Sdn Bhd, Lee Yong Chiew (YC Lee Architect) and Zahiruddin Zainal, who practises as Town Planning Services. Also in 2020, Genting appealed to the Pahang Planning Appeals Board against the project approval, but on 7 April 2021, the appeals filed by Genting and Genting Malaysia were dismissed.
The trial lasted 76 days over six years and featured expert witness testimony from both sides: six witnesses for Genting and nine for the defendants. The defendants argued that the lawsuit was an abuse of court process and a deliberate attempt to block development and eliminate a competitor at the highland resort.
Aliza then granted Genting’s application for a declaration that the earthworks were unlawful and contravened the approval granted by the local authority. The court also granted injunctive relief to prevent further slope modifications, excavation and use of support structures, emphasising that the safety risks and unlawful construction justified preventive measures.
The defendants are now appealing part of the decision. The 275-page grounds of judgment were issued on 29 Oct and uploaded to the e-Judgement website on 16 Nov, while the matter is now awaiting a hearing at the Court of Appeal.
Previously, we looked at a court ruling on the negligence of a contractor and ministry in the Labis property dispute over the loss of land access.