Private equity investors raise concerns over continuation vehicle exits
Tensions are increasing in private equity as co-investors object to being pushed out of company stakes when buyout groups transfer assets into continuation vehicles. The dispute adds to broader scrutiny of these transactions, which have expanded as firms struggle to sell portfolio companies to outside buyers and face questions over pricing and conflicts of interest.
Highlights
- Continuation vehicles accounted for about a fifth of all buyout exits last year as private equity groups struggled to find third-party buyers.
- Large private equity backers complain that co-investors are often forced to exit direct stakes too cheaply and denied rollover options in continuation vehicle deals.
- A lawsuit filed by Michael Maillis alleges HIG Capital sold Maillis Group assets to another HIG fund at a price previously rejected from an external bidder, without offering Maillis a rollover option.
Co-investor rights in continuation deals
As reported by the Financial Times, large backers of private equity funds are raising new complaints that co-investors are often forced to sell their holdings too cheaply when assets are moved into continuation vehicles.These vehicles, which buyout firms raise to acquire companies from their older funds, have become more common in recent years. Institutions often receive co-investment opportunities without fees as an incentive to support a fund, but some investors say they are then denied the option to keep those direct stakes when the same assets are sold into a new vehicle managed by the same sponsor.
One adviser to major buyout funds says some co-investors do not want to begin paying fees on stakes rolled into continuation vehicles. But he adds that investors are often not offered any rollover choice because their original access to the co-investment was tied to the specific fund that first bought the asset. Large investors say they want the right to decide for themselves whether to exit or remain invested.
One large private equity investor says it has spent substantial time and money fighting for that right, while a sovereign wealth fund also describes the treatment of co-investors in some continuation transactions as problematic. Another investor says minority holders can usually be forced out in an arm's-length sale, but that standard should not apply in conflicted deals where the same manager is effectively both seller and buyer.
Pricing pressure and conflict concerns
Continuation vehicles now account for about a fifth of all buyout exits last year, reflecting their growing role as private equity groups struggle to find third-party buyers. That rise is intensifying investor frustration because weak market conditions can leave co-investors at risk of being removed from growing companies at the same or even below their entry valuation.Investors in the selling funds have repeatedly warned that they can lose out unless these deals are subject to rigorous checks proving that the assets are sold at a full market price. The structure creates an inherent conflict of interest because the buyout manager controls both sides of the transaction.
A public example of those tensions emerges in a lawsuit brought last year by packaging entrepreneur Michael Maillis against a founder of U.S. buyout firm HIG Capital. The complaint says Maillis retained an indirect 15% stake in Maillis Group after HIG bought the business, and later alleges that HIG sold part of the company to another of its own funds in a cross-fund transaction similar to a continuation deal at a price it had previously rejected from an outside buyer.
The complaint says Maillis was never offered the option to keep his stake. HIG declines to comment, but a person familiar with the firm says the transaction is backed by a fairness opinion from a bank and that the firm is seeking to have the case dismissed.
As a reminder, our earlier coverage of the CVC Irca dispute showed how accounting concerns can unsettle private equity investors.