UK rejoining EU cost claim faces scrutiny over gross budget figure

UK rejoining EU cost claim faces scrutiny over gross budget figure
EU rejoin cost debated

Debate over the financial case for rejoining the EU is intensifying as campaigners revive a headline weekly cost figure for Britain. The £750 million estimate rests on a proposed 2028-34 EU budget and excludes money that would flow back to the UK, echoing disputes over how Brexit-era numbers were presented.

Highlights

  • Stay Out campaign claims rejoining the EU would cost the UK £750 million a week based on a gross calculation from the proposed €2 trillion EU budget for 2028-34.
  • The £750 million figure excludes potential return flows from EU funds and overlooks ongoing negotiations that could lower Britain's contributions or pandemic debt liabilities.
  • Economists like John Springford estimate Brexit has already cost the UK £3-3.5 billion in weekly national income and £1-1.3 billion in lost tax revenue, with OBR projecting a 4% long-term productivity hit.

Budget assumptions behind the £750 million claim

As reported by The Guardian, the Stay Out campaign group calculates that rejoining the EU would cost Britain £750 million a week, rounded down from £756 million, based on the European Commission's proposed €2 trillion long-term budget for 2028-34. The group assumes the UK would re-enter as a large and relatively wealthy member and make a contribution in line with its economic weight.

The figure is presented on a gross basis, meaning it excludes funding that could return to Britain through items such as farm subsidies and scientific research grants. That approach mirrors the method used by Vote Leave's £350 million a week claim during the 2016 referendum campaign, a figure the UK Statistics Authority later reprimanded as misleading because it omitted the British rebate and EU spending that came back to the UK.

Some of the assumptions behind the newer estimate remain contested. The EU's 2028-34 budget is still under negotiation, and the final settlement could be below the commission's €2 trillion proposal, with member states also discussing a €1.62 trillion compromise associated with Ireland's presidency of the Council of the EU.

Another disputed element is the assumption that a rejoining UK would help repay the bloc's pandemic recovery borrowing, estimated at €24 billion a year from 2028. Because that borrowing was agreed after the UK left the EU, critics argue any future British negotiators would be likely to challenge liability for costs incurred during its absence.

Economic impact debate goes beyond budget payments

Critics of the Stay Out analysis argue that focusing on gross budget contributions overlooks the wider economic effect of EU membership on trade, output and tax receipts. John Springford of the Centre for European Reform describes the £750 million figure as misleading because it excludes both the return flow of EU funds and the broader losses linked to Brexit.

Using calculations based on two studies of Brexit's economic cost, Springford says the UK's lost national income from being outside the EU amounts to between £3 billion and £3.5 billion a week. He also estimates an additional £1 billion to £1.3 billion in weekly tax revenue is lost because that economic activity is no longer being generated.

Other economic estimates point in a similar direction. The Office for Budget Responsibility says Brexit leaves the British economy 4% less productive in the long run, while Springford's own doppelganger model finds a 5.5% reduction in GDP and National Bureau of Economic Research work concludes Brexit results in a 6% to 8% hit to GDP by 2025.

Even so, economists do not suggest that rejoining the EU would automatically restore the pre-Brexit economy. Some export-oriented production may have shifted permanently, and investors may still question the durability of any renewed UK commitment, but the broader argument from pro-rejoin economists is that the long-term economic gains would still exceed the UK's net contribution to the EU budget.

Earlier, we looked at the UK Budget framework for ringfencing preventive spending through PDEL to fund early intervention programmes.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.