Yulia Slavina

U.S. housing market constraints weigh on labour mobility and growth

U.S. housing market constraints weigh on labour mobility and growth
Housing slows job growth

Housing shortages in the most productive parts of the U.S. are limiting workers’ ability to move to better-paying jobs and adding to broader economic frustration. The strain reflects both a long decline in homebuilding investment and regulatory barriers that have slowed construction in high-demand regions.

Highlights

  • U.S. residential fixed construction investment has declined from nearly 5% of GDP pre-2005 to 3.6% since 2008, with falling housing stock growth and supply concentrated away from high-wage regions.
  • Building supply costs are up 75% since early 2020 and higher interest rates, tariffs, and stricter immigration enforcement are further reducing both home demand and availability.
  • Restrictive zoning and permitting rules in high-income areas are causing severe housing supply bottlenecks, exacerbating regional labor immobility and limiting access to job-rich locations.

Investment slowdown and supply bottlenecks

As reported by the Financial Times, residential fixed construction investment in the U.S. has weakened markedly since the housing crash, falling from an average of just under 5 per cent of GDP in the postwar era through 2005 to 3.6 per cent since 2008. After a brief rebound a few years ago, that rate is falling again, reinforcing concerns that the housing market is not supplying enough homes where they are most needed.

The slowdown is visible in the growth of the national housing stock. In the 1970s, U.S. housing stock grew by 2.8 per cent a year, but by the 2010s that pace had dropped to 0.6 per cent. Even with population growth running at a similar rate over the past decade, the central issue is not only the number of homes, but also their location in regions with stronger wages and productivity.

Several cyclical pressures are also weighing on supply. Building costs have risen sharply, with the producer price index for building supplies up 75 per cent since early 2020, while tariffs on China and immigration enforcement at work sites have added to disruption for builders. Higher interest rates are also reducing both demand for homes and the supply of existing properties coming onto the market.

Regulatory barriers deepen regional imbalances

Beyond short-term cost pressures, the article argues that zoning and permitting rules dating back to the environmental and historic preservation movements of the 1960s and 1970s have become a major structural obstacle to new construction. In high-demand, high-income areas, these rules are increasingly seen as giving local opposition groups tools to block development.

Harvard housing economist Edward Glaeser says the combination of lower building volumes and sharply higher prices points clearly to a supply problem rooted in local land-use regulation. He argues that well-educated, high-demand communities have become particularly effective at stopping nearby development, limiting housing access in places with the strongest job opportunities.

The debate is also playing out in local politics. At a planning board meeting in Marblehead, Massachusetts, a resident publicly challenged efforts to weaken a state law intended to encourage multifamily construction, highlighting the tension between local resistance and broader housing needs.

The proposed remedy is a shift toward more predictable, by-right building rules and stronger incentives tied to actual housing construction rather than formal rule changes that can be diluted in practice. The broader economic implication is that unless policymakers expand affordable housing near areas of job growth, U.S. labour mobility and political stability are likely to remain under pressure.

As a reminder, we recently covered the single-family permits slump alongside an October rebound in U.S. housing starts.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.