UK CMA seeks MoD data-sharing to curb bid-rigging in defence procurement

UK CMA seeks MoD data-sharing to curb bid-rigging in defence procurement
CMA eyes MoD for data

The UK competition regulator is seeking broader government backing to strengthen oversight of the country's £400 billion annual public procurement market. Its latest push includes talks with the Ministry of Defence on using procurement data to detect possible collusion in defence supply chains.

Highlights

  • CMA seeks MoD procurement data access to apply its screening tool, aiming to detect suspicious bidding and address taxpayer losses up to £3.5 billion annually.
  • Current pilots with DWP, Department for Education, and Ministry of Justice generate enforcement leads, but a lack of central government commitment limits large-scale deployment.
  • UK debarment regime allows companies breaching competition law to be barred from public contracts for up to five years, intensifying scrutiny post-pandemic.

Procurement data push gathers pace

As reported by Financial Times, citing the Competition and Markets Authority, the regulator is exploring whether it can obtain Ministry of Defence procurement data and apply an in-house screening tool to tender records for suspicious bidding patterns.

The CMA says the discussions with the MoD form part of a wider effort to centralise the collection of government procurement data, which it believes would help it identify manipulation in public contracts that may be costing taxpayers up to £3.5 billion a year. The authority is already piloting the tool with the Department for Work and Pensions, the Department for Education and the Ministry for Justice, and says those trials are generating enforcement leads.

In a report, the regulator says government contracts are prime targets for bid-rigging because public purchasing combines large values, frequent transactions and system design features that make distortion easier. It adds that although several departments have shown willingness to work with the CMA, there is still no central cross-government commitment to deploy the capability at the scale needed for a broader impact.

Scrutiny of public procurement has intensified since the Covid-19 pandemic, when a number of government contracts raised concerns over transparency and conflicts of interest. A new debarment regime that came into force last year now allows companies found to have breached competition law to be barred from bidding for public contracts for as long as five years.

Defence sector risks and wider enforcement

The MoD talks follow comments last week from defence procurement minister Luke Pollard, who told MPs that the department is making progress in strengthening supply-chain data to better identify vulnerabilities and manage risk. The ministry says it is committed to improving supply-chain resilience across defence, including by working with the CMA to assess whether existing procurement data could support analysis of competition and market health in the sector.

Trevor Taylor, director of the defence, industries & society programme at the Rusi think-tank, says he is not aware of widespread bid-rigging in defence but that it makes sense to scan tender submissions for inconsistencies. He says the sector has unusual characteristics, including high barriers to entry and its central national security role, while large defence groups are often incentivised to spread work among smaller key suppliers to preserve capability and resilience.

Taylor warns that risks may be greater among non-defence specialist companies supplying generic products to the MoD, where costly collaboration between companies could be tempting. The CMA says data from losing bids is especially important in spotting suspicious behaviour, and argues the UK is falling behind countries including Spain, Portugal, South Korea and Brazil, where public procurement data collection is mandated to combat manipulation.

The regulator is also pursuing live enforcement work elsewhere. It is investigating suspected bid-rigging in roofing and other construction services supplied to schools eligible for Department for Education funding, and expanded that probe in January to cover more companies and potential victims.

Our earlier coverage of the CMA’s procurement data drive explained how the regulator is seeking access to government tender records—especially in the defence sector—to run screening tools that flag suspicious bidding patterns. We noted the CMA believes broader, centralised collection of procurement data could generate enforcement leads and help curb potential manipulation in public contracts, alongside tougher rules that can debar competition law offenders from bidding.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.