Central bank balance sheets likely to remain large as QT nears limits

Central bank balance sheets likely to remain large as QT nears limits
QT nearing practical limits

Major central banks have reduced their balance sheets from the peaks reached during the Covid-19 era, but the scale of that retreat now appears limited. Experience at the Federal Reserve, Bank of England and European Central Bank suggests quantitative tightening may be approaching practical constraints rather than returning portfolios to pre-crisis norms.

Highlights

  • Bank of England, European Central Bank, and Federal Reserve balance sheets have shrunk relative to nominal GDP to pre-pandemic levels, slowing QT progress.
  • Bank of England's active gilt sales and redemptions cut its balance sheet by over half since the 2022 peak, potentially raising UK borrowing costs by 0.7 percentage points.
  • Large central bank balance sheets are expected to become a lasting feature of monetary policy in the U.S., UK, and euro zone despite the end of large-scale asset purchases.

Balance sheet reduction slows across major central banks

As reported by the Financial Times, the balance sheets of the Bank of England, the European Central Bank and the Federal Reserve have fallen relative to nominal GDP to levels not seen since before the pandemic-era expansion, but recent experience indicates that further shrinkage may be difficult and unnecessary.

The Fed was the first of the three to begin normalising its balance sheet in 2017. That initial effort ended in August 2019, and stress in the repo market the following month showed that the reduction had gone too far. Its second round of quantitative tightening has been more orderly, but it ended late last year to avoid a repeat of that disruption.

The ECB started quantitative easing later than its peers and has also moved more slowly in unwinding it. Its balance sheet was already shrinking before formal quantitative tightening began, largely because banks were repaying crisis-era loans and nominal GDP was rising quickly.

UK cost pressures and broader market implications

The Bank of England has taken the most contested route, reducing its bond holdings through both maturities and outright gilt sales rather than relying only on passive runoff. As a share of GDP, its balance sheet has fallen by a little more than half from its 2022 peak, but that approach may also have raised UK borrowing costs, with some estimates putting the effect at as much as 0.7 percentage points.

The BoE is due to decide on September 17 how much further to shrink its balance sheet over the coming year. For the ECB, caution reflects the added difficulty of preserving financial stability across a 21-country currency union.

While the period of large-scale asset purchases may be over, the overall picture points to a lasting structural shift in central banking. Large balance sheets are likely to remain a feature of monetary policy frameworks in the U.S., UK and euro zone.

Our earlier report on the UK state pension triple lock explained how mounting Budget pressure and higher bond yields are intensifying calls to curb welfare spending by moving from the triple lock to a double lock or an earnings link. We noted that the policy’s rising long-term cost is increasingly framed as a generational trade-off, with proposals to redirect any savings toward easing tax and employment pressures on younger workers.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.