Hlib Chabaniuk

Pakistan rice sector faces competitiveness pressure as export subsidy debate deepens

Pakistan rice sector faces competitiveness pressure as export subsidy debate deepens
Pakistan rice sector pressured

After a record performance in FY2024, Pakistan's rice export sector is under pressure as volumes and earnings decline and concerns grow over the effectiveness of state support. The debate now extends beyond exporters to the wider rice value chain, including farmers, taxpayers and the country's external accounts.

Highlights

  • Pakistan's rice exports projected to decline to 4.3 million tons and USD 2.3 billion in FY2026 from 6 million tons and USD 3.89 billion in FY2024, widening the gap with India's record 21.57 million tons and USD 11.53 billion in the same period.
  • The Ministry of Commerce allocates Rs15 billion via DLTL with a 9 percent incentive for Basmati and 5 percent for non-Basmati, yet export volume weakens and Customs finds over-invoicing and misdeclaration risks.
  • Policy proposals recommend ending open-ended export subsidies, redirecting funds into digital, farm-level support and seed research, and introducing stricter real-time export verification amid rising logistics costs.

Subsidy design and export slowdown

As reported by Pakistan Business Recorder, Pakistan's rice exports fall to about 4.3 million tons in FY2026 from a record six million tons worth USD 3.89 billion in FY2024, while earnings decline to USD 2.3 billion. Over the same period, India exports a record 21.57 million tons worth USD 11.53 billion, underscoring the competitive gap in regional rice trade.

The Ministry of Commerce allocates Rs15 billion under the Drawback of Local Tax and Levies, or DLTL, with exporters assuring an additional USD 1 billion to USD 1.5 billion in exports by June 2026. The scheme initially offers 9 percent for Basmati and 3 percent for non-Basmati rice, before being extended to September 30 with non-Basmati support raised to 5 percent.

The industry argues that the incentive is necessary because Indian Basmati is about USD 250 per ton cheaper than Pakistan's product. Even so, exports continue to weaken, while reported increases in declared Basmati export prices after the DLTL launch raise concerns about over-invoicing and misdeclaration of rice varieties.

Pakistan Customs subsequently detects discrepancies in rice consignments, intensifying scrutiny of whether a subsidy tied to declared export values creates incentives for abuse. The article argues that if support fails to restore competitiveness while potentially encouraging manipulation, the fiscal cost to taxpayers becomes harder to justify.

Structural costs and policy shift

An export subsidy may temporarily improve overseas pricing, but the broader concern is that higher domestic procurement costs can shift the burden onto Pakistani consumers while benefits accrue to hoarders, traders and exporters with offshore operations. Farmers remain exposed to rising input costs, including fertiliser, diesel, electricity, seed, pesticides, machinery and labour, and often sell quickly after harvest to meet cash needs.

The piece argues that scarce public funds should move away from port-based incentives and freight support toward productivity gains at farm level. Suggested measures include support for certified high-yield Basmati and non-Basmati seed, water-saving irrigation, laser land levelling, mechanisation, paddy dryers, scientific storage, soil testing, extension services and traceability systems that meet international food-safety requirements.

A proposed Rice Grower Support Voucher would provide registered farmers with discounts on certified seed, fertiliser, pesticides, efficient irrigation and solar-powered pumping, with transfers for small farmers routed through verified bank or Pakistan Post accounts. The aim is to reduce production costs at source rather than subsidise shipments after output has already entered the export chain.

The disruption around the Strait of Hormuz adds to freight, insurance, vessel availability and routing costs, with freight from Indian and Pakistani ports to Jeddah reportedly rising from about USD 500 per 20-foot container to USD 3,500 before easing toward USD 2,300. But the article notes that this is a global logistics shock affecting competing exporters as well, meaning freight compensation would not solve Pakistan's underlying structural disadvantage.

The proposed policy reset includes ending open-ended export subsidies with a clear sunset mechanism for DLTL, redirecting funds to transparent digital farmer support, investing in indigenous seed research and climate-resilient varieties, and strengthening real-time verification of export values and rice varieties through Customs, the Pakistan Single Window and banks. It also calls for firmer action against hoarding and for exporters to shift from bulk trading toward branded, packaged and traceable Pakistani Basmati to capture more value.

Our earlier article on Pakistan’s industrial electricity tariff debate explained why the country’s business lobby is pushing to cut power prices from about 12 cents per unit to below 9 cents to strengthen export competitiveness and reduce reliance on imports. It also highlighted concerns that existing packages and two-part time-of-use tariffs may offer limited relief because fixed charges remain high and any benefits could be shifted elsewhere in the system rather than lowering industry’s underlying cost base.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.