Germany, UK reject U.S. criticism of Ukraine deep-strike strategy before Trump-Putin-Xi talks
European allies are publicly defending Ukraine’s long-range attacks inside Russia as a policy rift emerges with Washington ahead of high-level talks in China. The disagreement surfaces before a planned meeting on Thursday between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in Shenzhen.
Highlights
- Germany’s Defense Minister Pistorius and UK Defence Secretary Streeting reject U.S. criticism of Ukraine’s deep-strike campaign, citing its importance in degrading Russia’s war machine.
- U.S. Undersecretary of Defense Colby claims Ukraine’s deep strikes inside Russia have been ineffective in ending the war or halting Russian advances, while mid-range strikes are more successful.
- Ukraine increases attacks on Russian oil infrastructure and the Kerch Bridge as leaders prepare for a Trump-Putin-Xi summit, raising the war’s economic and symbolic costs for Moscow.
Allied split over Ukraine strike tactics
As reported by CNBC, Germany and the UK are pushing back against U.S. criticism of Ukraine’s deep-strike campaign inside Russia, exposing differences among Kyiv’s backers over how the war should be fought. The dispute intensifies as the Trump administration weighs the military value and political consequences of attacks beyond the front line.Speaking at NATO headquarters in Belgium on Tuesday, U.S. Undersecretary of Defense Elbridge Colby says Ukraine’s deep strikes inside Russia "have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia’s advances on the front line." He says Ukraine’s mid-range strike campaign using newer drone technologies and tactics to deny Russian advances has been "very effective," and notes that Ukraine’s Armed Forces gain more territory than Russia for the second consecutive month in October.
Colby also says strikes targeting what he describes as civilian infrastructure inside Russia probably harden Russian public resolve and the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate. Kyiv says warehouses hit by Ukrainian drones are involved in supplying Russian forces with drone components, navigation equipment and other military parts, while Wildberries and the Kremlin deny the company is involved in Russia’s war effort.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius says criticism of strikes intended to destroy strategic military and dual-use targets in Russia "is quite a stupid thing, I think." UK Defence Secretary Wes Streeting echoes that position, saying it is "not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war" and adding that the campaign helps degrade Putin’s war machine, buy time and save lives.
Diplomatic stakes and war impact
Beyond the immediate military debate, the clash highlights broader strains between Washington and European capitals as leaders prepare for Thursday’s trilateral meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi. Trade, artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons are expected to dominate the agenda, but outside observers are also watching closely for any discussion of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.Trump has previously called on Ukraine to stop strikes on Russian oil refineries and infrastructure used to produce and distribute diesel, arguing the attacks are responsible for a global shortage. Ukraine, however, is stepping up attacks on Russian oil facilities and logistics infrastructure in recent months as it seeks to raise the cost of the war for Moscow after more than 4½ years of conflict.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on Tuesday praises what he calls an "unprecedented operation" targeting the Kerch Bridge linking Russia to occupied Crimea, in a symbolic blow to the Kremlin’s war effort. A coordinated drone and missile strike damages the bridge, a key road and rail supply route for Russian forces and one of Putin’s signature projects, while Russia says the crossing will be restored and "will be even better than before."
As we previously wrote, the upcoming Xi-Trump-Putin summit at APEC in Shenzhen is expected to test trade and security priorities.