ECB pushes banking simplification to lift European lenders' competitiveness
European banks have improved profitability, asset quality and returns on equity, but the sector still faces structural limits to long-term competitiveness. Those constraints stem mainly from market fragmentation and regulatory complexity, which the European Central Bank says continue to hold back scale, innovation and cross-border expansion.
Highlights
- The ECB, through Pedro Machado, announced a shift from designing to implementing simplification measures such as faster capital decisions and lighter reporting burdens for European banks.
- Machado emphasized that despite stronger profitability, better cost-to-income ratios, and improved asset quality, fragmentation along national lines remains the biggest barrier to European banks' competitiveness.
- The persistent lack of cross-border mergers in the EU banking sector limits efficiency gains and revenue diversification, making regulatory simplification and deeper integration urgent priorities.
ECB sets out simplification agenda
According to European Central Bank, as stated in a speech by the ECB Supervisory Arm, Pedro Machado, member of the ECB Supervisory Board, says competitiveness and simplification are becoming a shared agenda for European banks and supervisors. He argues that stronger capital and supervision do not weaken lenders' ability to compete, but instead support lending capacity, shock absorption and investment confidence.Machado says European banks are in a stronger position than they were a few years ago, with profitability catching up to U.S. peers, cost-to-income ratios comparing favourably and asset quality improving markedly. He says competitiveness should not be judged by a single quarter's results, but by whether banks remain resilient, efficient and innovative, and whether they can deploy technologies such as artificial intelligence effectively over time.
The ECB is now moving from designing simplification measures to implementing them, he says. The measures include faster capital decisions, a lighter reporting burden, more efficient on-site work and updates to the rulebook, while keeping prudential standards unchanged.
Fragmentation remains a structural constraint
Machado says the main obstacle for European banks is not a lack of resilience but persistent fragmentation along national lines. He points to the Draghi report's assessment that the EU banking sector is a bottleneck for competitiveness because of fragmentation, regulatory complexity and a lack of scale compared with U.S. rivals.He says this fragmentation raises costs for banks' strategic planning, especially in digital transformation and service innovation, while the limited number of cross-border mergers prevents lenders from gaining efficiency and diversifying revenue. In his view, national markets alone cannot provide the scale and diversification needed for European banks to stay competitive, making delivery on simplification and broader integration a priority for supervisors, policymakers and the industry.
Our earlier article on tougher capital rules for UBS explained that Swiss lawmakers backed stricter requirements that could force the bank to hold about $18 billion in additional capital. We also noted that the debate has intensified around UBS’s future structure, including potential merger interest, while Swiss officials signalled that relocating the bank would likely be more costly and legally complex than complying.