MSCI analysis flags higher external-fund redemption costs as anti-dilution rules expand
Institutional investors in external funds may face materially higher exit costs as anti-dilution tools become more widely used across open-end funds. MSCI estimates these charges can climb sharply in stressed markets and rise further when large simultaneous outflows force funds to pass more trading costs to redeeming investors.
Highlights
- EU rules from April 2026 and new UK mandates require open-end fund managers to adopt anti-dilution tools, shifting higher trading costs to redeeming investors.
- MSCI estimates that after the April 2025 U.S. tariff announcement, redeeming USD 100 million from global high-yield bond funds saw costs jump 42% to 49 basis points.
- Concurrent large-scale outflows can amplify redemption costs up to 280% for small- and mid-cap equity funds versus withdrawing the same amount with no net outflows.
Redemption cost pressures under new fund rules
As reported by MSCI, the growing use of anti-dilution tools is shifting the cost of fund withdrawals from remaining investors to those redeeming their holdings. Tools such as swing pricing and anti-dilution levies are designed to pass through trading expenses created when funds sell assets to raise cash.The change is gaining regulatory backing. European Union rules effective from April 2026 require managers of open-end funds to select at least two liquidity-management tools, while new UK rules require anti-dilution mechanisms when dilution creates a material risk.
MSCI says transaction costs tied to redemptions include bid-ask spreads and market impact, and these can increase significantly in periods of market stress, especially for funds invested in less liquid assets. That means investors planning withdrawals may need to account not only for normal dealing costs but also for how market conditions affect the price of exiting a fund.
Market stress and outflows amplify investor charges
MSCI's estimates show redemption costs rose across several fund types after the April 2025 U.S. tariff announcement. The modeled cost of redeeming USD 100 million from a global high-yield bond fund increased by 42%, to 49 basis points from 34 basis points, while global investment-grade bond funds rose 27%, to 21.6 basis points from 17 basis points, and developed-market large-cap equity funds rose 10%, to 3.2 basis points from 2.9 basis points.The analysis also points to a separate cost driver, the scale of other investors' withdrawals on the same day. During the tariff-related stress episode, a USD 100 million redemption amid USD 1 billion in net outflows could cost 170% more in developed-market large-cap equity funds, 280% more in small- and mid-cap equity funds, and 220% more in emerging-market equity funds than redeeming the same amount alone.
For fixed-income funds, the added effect is smaller, at about 30% for emerging-market bonds, 16% for global high-yield bonds and 12% for global investment-grade bonds. MSCI says this reflects the way trading costs respond to size, with bond funds typically carrying higher baseline transaction costs but equity-fund costs reacting more sharply when aggregate redemptions increase.
The firm says investors often lack full visibility into fund holdings and cannot predict other investors' withdrawals in advance, making redemption costs difficult to estimate. It suggests institutional investors may need to model the liquidity of their external fund exposures directly and stress test potential exit costs under different market and flow scenarios.
We have also analyzed how Moody’s credit validation gave European private credit managers an external benchmark for LP due diligence.