Michael Batnick: Owning largest S&P 500 stock has underperformed owning overall index

Traders Union
All News
Market Voices
Top S&P 500 stocks have lagged index

Top Stories

Editors' Picks

Stocks

Crypto

Economics

Currencies

Commodities

Business & Wealth

Market Voices

4 hours ago

Michael Batnick: Owning largest S&P 500 stock has underperformed owning overall index — Top S&P 500 stocks have lagged index

Owning the largest stock in the S&P 500 has historically delivered lower returns compared to simply holding the overall index, according to Michael Batnick. Batnick, identified as Managing Partner and Director of Research, shared his long-standing interest in a chart from NDR Research that illustrates this trend.

View post on X Loading...

The tweet was deleted by the author.

But we saved everything 🙂.

Batnick has previously commented on cash positions among major tech firms. He noted that Anthropic's cash holdings exceed those of all Magnificent 7 companies except Alphabet in a recent article (read more). His observations continue to track shifts in large-cap company metrics.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.

Did you like the article?

#Michael Batnick

Editor's Picks for You

How China is turning AI credits into Singles’ Day’s newest staple

By Dmytro Kharkov
7 hours ago

How China is turning AI credits into Singles’ Day’s newest staple

Editors' Picks

Banks vs. crypto companies: Who better protects your money from hackers?

By Elena Nikulina
10 hours ago

Banks vs. crypto companies: Who better protects your money from hackers?

Editors' Picks

U.S. elections: What awaits the crypto industry after the Democrats' victory?

By Eugene Komchuk
14 hours ago

U.S. elections: What awaits the crypto industry after the Democrats' victory?

Editors' Picks

All Editors' Top Picks

Latest Michael Batnick News

Anthropic surpasses Mag 7 peers in cash reserves except Alphabet, Michael Batnick notes

By Yaroslav Dmytrenko
30.10.2026

Anthropic surpasses Mag 7 peers in cash reserves except Alphabet, Michael Batnick notes

Market Voices

#Michael Batnick

Michael Batnick: Berkshire could fall 99 percent and still match S&P 500 growth since 1965

By Elena Nikulina
23.09.2026

Michael Batnick: Berkshire could fall 99 percent and still match S&P 500 growth since 1965

Market Voices

#Michael Batnick

All Michael Batnick News

Dmytro Kharkov
7 hours ago

How China is turning AI credits into Singles’ Day’s newest staple

Elena Nikulina
10 hours ago

Banks vs. crypto companies: Who better protects your money from hackers?

Eugene Komchuk
14 hours ago

U.S. elections: What awaits the crypto industry after the Democrats' victory?

Anastasiia Chabaniuk
Yesterday

From Coinbase to Visa: Who makes money from blockchain?

Mikhail Vnuchkov
Yesterday

One of the biggest M&A deals: Why is Marvell buying Lumentum?

Pavlo Kot
12 min ago

Michael Taylor: Machines are driving stock movements in current market

Hanna Syniavska
27 min ago

Peter Schiff: DJT shares close at all-time low, down 95% from 2022 high

Mykhailo Ihnatenko
42 min ago

Anthropic pre-IPO trading limited to one main place, Spencer Hakimian notes

Yaroslav Dmytrenko
46 min ago

Stock market climbed on expectations of reduced AI spending after U.S. midterm election, Steve Hou notes

Pavlo Kot
46 min ago

Market may anticipate end of MAGA tax, James Pethokoukis suggests

Top News

Oleksii Zaichenko
7 hours ago

Bitcoin tops $80,500 as U.S. stocks rally after midterm elections

Bitcoin tops $80,500 as U.S. stocks rally after midterm elections

Dmytro Kharkov
7 hours ago

How China is turning AI credits into Singles’ Day’s newest staple

How China is turning AI credits into Singles’ Day’s newest staple

Andrey Mastykin
9 hours ago

Oil extends losses as U.S. midterm results fuel Iran peace hopes

Oil extends losses as U.S. midterm results fuel Iran peace hopes

Igor Krasulya
10 hours ago

Wall Street futures soar after Democrats win Congress

Wall Street futures soar after Democrats win Congress

Hanna Syniavska
11 hours ago

Eurozone inflation hits three-year high as energy costs fuel price surge

Eurozone inflation hits three-year high as energy costs fuel price surge

Top 5 companies for you

United States

Live News

Igor Krasulya
Now

Demand for Meta debut euro bonds exceeds offering size sixfold

Olga Shendetskaya
Now

McDonald's reports first sales decline in 18 months

Anton Kharitonov
Now

EUR/USD tests 1.1270 as U.S. election results and eurozone inflation boost the euro

Mykhailo Ihnatenko
Now

AMD stock jumps over 6% after record earnings and strong Q4 outlook

Eugene Komchuk
Now

Morgan Stanley joins Wall Street asset tokenization initiative

© IAFT Ltd., 2010-2026 All rights to the website are owned by IAFT Ltd.,
Registration number - HE 336186

Risk disclosure:

Information on the TradersUnion.com website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute any motive or suggestion to visitors to invest money. Moreover, we hereby warn you that trading on the Forex and CFD markets is always a high risk. According to the statistics, 75-89% of customers lose the funds invested and only 11-25% of traders earn a profit. Trading in futures and options carries substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for every investor.

That is why you should only invest money that you are prepared — or can afford — to lose at such high risks. Tradersunion.com does not provide any financial services, including investment or financial advisory services. Also, the Traders Union is not a broker and does not get money for trading in the Forex or CFD markets. Our website only provides information on brokers and the markets and helps its users to select the best brokerage company based on detailed information and objective analysis of brokers.
Disclaimer:

Traders Union (TradersUnion.com) shall not be liable for the consequences of trading decisions made by the Client and for the possible loss of his capital resulting from the use of this website and information published on it.

Forex market, CFD and cryptocurrency trading involves high risks and is not suitable for everyone. Before investing money, you need to adequately assess the level of your expertise and be aware of the risks, particularly in the context of trading with leverage. The information on this website is not intended for distribution or use by any person in any country or jurisdiction, where such distribution or use would be in violation of the local law or regulation. Any payments by Traders Union (TradersUnion.com) to the users of our website shall be legally interpreted solely as an incentive on our part for the activity on the website in the form of a deduction of a part of the advertising income; they shall not be a subject of any claims of our users or our obligations, a subject of disputes, as well as cannot be considered in relation to the services provided to users by brokers, both in fact and in their completeness and volume. The administration of the website shall not be liable for the content of user comments and reviews about the companies and shall not verify whether the authors of the reviews are indeed real clients of a specific company. All reviews, both negative and positive are published on the website without verification of their reliability; only offensive reviews that call for violence or any kind of discrimination and also reviews published from one group of IP addresses are moderated and removed. The authors of the materials shall be fully liable for the accuracy, completeness and impartiality of any information in the articles and reviews, including in the context of their use or mention of any brand names or trademarks. All mentions of the names of companies and their brands in any materials on the website shall be made in the context of communication of socially important information to the people about their activities by independent journalists, who are the authors. All evaluations and indicators on the website express the subjective opinion of the authors of the reviews (articles) and shall not be viewed as accurate statements and be a subject of disputes and claims against Traders Union.
Disclosure of advertisers and revenues:

All the services on the Tradersunion.com website are free for you to use. Our team spends thousands of hours per annum researching brokers and gathering information about them to help investors all over the world to choose reliable companies and to avoid fraudsters.

Indeed, the curating, sourcing, and organization of this process requires substantial financial investment by Tradersunion.com, which the website earns in the form of advertising payments. There are two types of advertising services on the website — direct advertising or partner (broker) participation programs. However, no services purchased by our partners shall affect the recommendations on our website, or our opinions, or ratings. Our ratings are based on our objective rating criteria and methodology; and the results are always equally and fairly applied to each broker. The work of our content authors and research groups does not involve any interaction with our advertisers and they do not have access to data concerning the amount of advertising purchased. For over 10 years we consider our independence, absolute openness, and objectivity as our main priority. Please follow the links to each of our affiliated broker’s websites. This will help Tradersunion.com to continue to provide our services to you for free.