American Portfolios faces $1.6 million FINRA penalty over UIT supervision failures
American Portfolios Financial Services is ordered to return more than $1.2 million plus interest to customers and pay a $400,000 fine over failures to supervise unit investment trust recommendations. The sanctions stem from repeated early UIT sales that caused 295 investors to incur avoidable charges before the firm became part of Osaic Wealth in October 2024.
Highlights
- FINRA fined American Portfolios $1.6 million for failing to supervise early unit investment trust (UIT) sales between January 2018 and October 2024.
- Three representatives caused 295 investors to incur $1,232,939 in unnecessary costs and fees by recommending early UIT sales, triggering individual restitution up to $399,055.29.
- This enforcement action forms part of FINRA's ongoing focus on UIT oversight, following a 2016 initiative that resulted in $16.8 million in restitution across six firms.
FINRA order targets UIT oversight gaps
As reported by FINRA, citing the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, the regulator says American Portfolios failed to maintain a supervisory system, including written policies and procedures, reasonably designed to review whether recommendations to sell unit investment trusts before maturity complied with FINRA Rule 2111 and Regulation Best Interest's Care Obligation.UITs typically hold a fixed portfolio of securities and end on a set maturity date, often after 15 or 24 months. Because these products are generally intended to be held to maturity, early sales followed by purchases of new UITs can trigger extra sales charges that investors would otherwise avoid.
FINRA says that from January 2018 to October 2024, American Portfolios customers bought about $470 million in UITs. During that period, the firm's controls did not adequately identify representatives who repeatedly recommended early UIT sales and reinvestment into new UITs.
Customer restitution and broader enforcement focus
According to FINRA's findings, two representatives working as a team recommended early UIT sales about 61% of the time, with customers holding the investments for only about half of their term lengths on average. A third representative recommended early sales 78% of the time, with those customers also holding UITs for just over half of their expected terms.Together, the three representatives caused 295 investors to pay $1,232,939 in unnecessary costs and fees, FINRA says. Individual restitution ranges from $102.27 to $399,055.29, and the firm consents to the findings without admitting or denying the charges.
Bill St. Louis, FINRA's executive vice president and head of enforcement, says the action is intended to return money to customers who paid unnecessary costs and reinforces member firms' obligation to monitor recommendation patterns that may harm investors. FINRA also says the case follows its longer-running scrutiny of UIT supervision after a 2016 sweep led to settlements with six firms and more than $16.8 million in restitution for about 10,000 investors.
Our earlier coverage of DoorDash’s $131.5 million settlement with New York City explained how the company agreed to pay fines and back pay over alleged underpayments and delayed compensation for app-based delivery workers. We noted that the dispute centered on pay calculations for time spent logged into the app but not actively delivering, plus remedies for missed or late payments, underscoring the compliance risks tied to complex, tech-driven systems.