EBA explores alternatives to EU deposit insurance plan for cross-border lending
European policymakers are revisiting how to deepen banking integration as longstanding divisions continue to block a full common deposit insurance framework. The European Banking Authority is now examining other tools that could make national supervisors more comfortable with cross-border capital and liquidity flows in a crisis.
Highlights
- EBA and European Commission are exploring alternatives to a full European Deposit Insurance Scheme to support cross-border lending, aiming to bypass political obstacles.
- A two-tier framework is under discussion where larger banks would join a European-level scheme linked to the Single Resolution Fund, while smaller lenders remain under national guarantees.
- Fragmentation in EU banking persists, as the five largest EU banks hold 31% of domestic market assets versus 45% for top U.S. banks, with EBA set to opine on optimal EU capital levels.
Alternative framework under discussion
As reported by the Financial Times, European Banking Authority chair François-Louis Michaud says the regulator is working with the European Commission on new arrangements to support more cross-border lending without relying on a full European Deposit Insurance Scheme.Michaud says the aim is to give national authorities stronger assurances that banks will support subsidiaries in other EU countries during stress. He says the EBA has started discussing the options with its board and other authorities, while looking for solutions that sit outside the politically contentious deposit insurance debate.
The Commission says the debate should not be reduced to a choice between fully mutualised losses, a liquidity-only backstop, or no progress at all. Brussels set out plans earlier this year to review and simplify the EU deposit insurance framework at both central and national levels, and detailed proposals are expected in the first quarter of next year as part of broader banking reforms.
One idea under discussion is a two-tier system in which larger banks would be covered by a European-level scheme built on the existing Single Resolution Fund, while smaller lenders would remain under national guarantee schemes. A linked liquidity mechanism would connect the two layers, although it remains unclear whether that support would be temporary in a crisis or would also absorb losses if national funds prove insufficient.
Political obstacles and market pressure
Resistance remains strong in countries including Germany and the Netherlands, which have long opposed any arrangement that could mutualise losses across the bloc. Other countries are also wary of separating large banks from smaller lenders, arguing that national schemes funded by banks could be left under-resourced.The lack of a common deposit insurance framework has long been cited by banks as a barrier to cross-border consolidation because national authorities are less willing to allow funds to move freely among subsidiaries in different member states. The Commission first proposed a common scheme in 2015, but negotiations stalled after objections that it could encourage riskier behaviour by banks.
The EBA is also examining more targeted alternatives, including binding commitments from parent banks to fund foreign subsidiaries in a crisis, enforced by supervisors. Another route would encourage banks to follow Nordic groups such as SEB and Nordea, which have simplified cross-border structures by turning national subsidiaries into branches with lighter capital and liquidity requirements.
Michaud says broader fragmentation also holds back the EU banking market, pointing to differences in consumer protection, customer onboarding, taxation and insolvency rules. He adds that EU banks are losing share in lending to non-financial companies in their home markets to foreign rivals and non-bank lenders such as private credit groups, while scale pressures are increasing as banks face substantial investment needs in AI and other technologies.
The Commission's analysis shows the five biggest U.S. banks hold a combined 45% share of total banking assets in their home market, compared with 31% for the five largest EU lenders in the bloc. Michaud rejects claims that EU banks are simply disadvantaged by tougher capital rules than Wall Street peers, saying EBA calculations show U.S. requirements remain stricter even after recent easing, but he says the authority plans for the first time to give its view on the optimal capital level for EU banks to provide more certainty on the direction of regulation.
We have also discussed the broader context around the EBA’s NGFS declaration on embedding climate and energy shocks into EU banking oversight.