Weiss Ratings analysis shows wide Medigap premium gaps across U.S. states

Weiss Ratings analysis shows wide Medigap premium gaps across U.S. states
Huge Medigap premium gaps

State-level pricing differences are driving sharp cost variations in Medicare Supplement coverage for seniors buying standardized Medigap plans. Weiss Ratings says the gap between the cheapest and costliest states reaches thousands of dollars a year for identical benefits, underscoring the financial impact of geography on coverage costs.

Highlights

  • Weiss Ratings analysis finds Maryland the most expensive for Plan A Medigap at $6,652 annually for men, while Alaska is cheapest at $2,100.
  • For Plan G, New York leads with $5,569 annual premiums for both sexes, about $900 higher than second-place Minnesota, with Wisconsin as the lowest at $2,230 for men.
  • Weiss Ratings reports intra-state premium gaps can exceed 20-fold, urging consumers to compare insurers and check financial strength before buying coverage.

Premium rankings for Plan A and Plan G

As reported by Weiss Ratings, its latest analysis ranks the five most expensive and five cheapest states for a 65-year-old purchasing either basic Plan A or broader Plan G Medigap coverage. The agency says federal rules standardize Medigap benefits, meaning the same plan covers the same claims regardless of location, even as premiums differ sharply from state to state.

For Plan A, Weiss Ratings says Maryland is the most expensive state for a 65-year-old man at an average annual premium of $6,652, while Alaska is the cheapest at $2,100, tied with Massachusetts for men. For women, Alaska is also the least expensive at $1,911, and New Mexico, Utah and Massachusetts also appear on the cheapest-state lists for both sexes.

For Plan G, New York is the most expensive state for both men and women at $5,569 a year, about $900 above second-place Minnesota, according to the analysis. Wisconsin is the cheapest for Plan G at $2,230 for men and $2,007 for women, followed by New Mexico and Virginia.

Consumer costs and insurer comparison

Gavin Magor, director of ratings at Weiss Ratings, says the findings show that where a senior lives is influencing price far more than the benefits purchased. He also says consumers who accept the first quote offered may pay substantially more than other buyers receiving the same coverage from another insurer.

The agency highlights Maryland as an example of intra-state price dispersion, saying the highest Plan A quote it has seen there is more than 20 times the lowest. Weiss Ratings advises consumers to compare each company selling a Medigap plan in their state and to review the insurer's financial strength before buying or renewing coverage.

We have previously noted Weiss Ratings’ Safe Money Report as a retirement-focused publication centered on safety-oriented income strategies.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.