Nats defends dividend payments as UK outage scrutiny pressures air traffic operator
Pressure on the UK’s air traffic control system is intensifying after September disruption grounded 2,000 flights and left passengers stranded. Nats chief executive Martin Rolfe says dividend payments to shareholders do not come at the expense of technology investment and argues the group’s ownership model depends on maintaining returns.
Highlights
- Nats has paid £849mn in dividends since 2001 while investing £3.3bn in technology, defending ongoing payouts despite airline and UK government scrutiny.
- The September outage, which grounded 2,000 flights and cost carriers over £60mn, was caused by a millisecond system conflict now fixed to prevent recurrence.
- Intense industry pressure continues after two incidents and Ryanair calls for leadership overhaul, as the UK government orders a six-month independent investigation into Nats' outage response.
Ownership model and outage response
As reported by Financial Times, Rolfe defended Nats’ decision to continue paying dividends to owners including the UK government and airline shareholders, saying the sums involved are small relative to long-term spending on systems and infrastructure.Nats is 49 per cent owned by the UK government, while airlines including British Airways and easyJet hold 42 per cent and staff own about 5 per cent. Since becoming a public-private partnership in 2001, the organisation has paid £849mn in dividends and invested £3.3bn in technology and systems.
Rolfe says halting dividends would not materially change investment levels but would undermine the case for private investors to remain involved. He adds that without those investors, Nats would have to return to government ownership.
The September breakdown has sharpened criticism from airlines after the system outage grounded 2,000 flights and costs carriers more than £60mn without compensation. British Airways chief executive Sean Doyle says the airline would accept stopping dividends if that were needed to strengthen the resilience of the air traffic service.
Industry pressure and leadership questions
Rolfe says engineers have fixed the specific fault behind the September collapse, which Nats found was triggered when a flight plan and another instruction were received in the same millisecond. He says the updated system can now handle two requests arriving at the same instant and that the same problem cannot recur.He also says a separate issue at Prestwick in Scotland almost two weeks later has been resolved. Even so, the incidents have intensified pressure on Nats and on Rolfe personally, with Ryanair chief Michael O’Leary calling for his resignation and wider board changes.
Rolfe argues that demands for sweeping reform underestimate the complexity of running one of the world’s most congested airspaces, where Nats handles more than 2.5mn flights a year. He says air traffic operators globally face similar challenges in integrating new technology into older systems, pointing to the recent U.S. outage caused by an overloaded remote router.
Nats is also dealing with a worldwide shortage of air traffic controllers and the cost and time needed to train new staff. The UK government has commissioned the Civil Aviation Authority to conduct an independent six-month investigation into the September incident, a process that is likely to keep scrutiny on Rolfe’s future even as he says succession is a matter for the board led by former Rolls-Royce chief executive Warren East.
We have previously detailed Malaysia's AI governance bill and its focus on board accountability for managing AI risks.