M&G opposes Spar board appointment as governance battle intensifies
Spar faces mounting pressure over its board composition as key shareholder M&G Investments pushes for wider retail and governance expertise at the group. The dispute centers on the planned appointment of former Massmart and Edcon chief executive Grant Pattison, while independent retailers and investors press for broader board renewal.
Highlights
- M&G Investments, holding just over 14% of Spar, opposes Pattison's board appointment citing governance concerns and conflicts with its Pick n Pay stake.
- M&G calls for an extraordinary general meeting to elect five new non-executive directors, including turnaround specialist Phil Roux and three candidates with direct Spar experience.
- The Spar Guild of Southern Africa supports retailer-backed board candidates amid mounting tensions over board renewal, high debt, and competition from on-demand services.
Shareholder campaign targets Spar board overhaul
As first reported by Moneyweb, M&G Investments does not support Pattison’s nomination to the Spar board, despite backing his retail credentials, because he recently resigned from the board of rival Pick n Pay and M&G holds significant stakes in both companies.M&G, which owns just over 14% of Spar, has called for an extraordinary general meeting to elect five directors, including two retailers, to the board. In a statement on Monday, the investment manager says the board’s composition requires urgent attention and that the range of skills needed is broader than the current appointment suggests.
Spar appointed acting chair Lwazi Koyana as permanent chair on 12 November and elected Pattison to the board, with his appointment set to take effect on 25 February 2027. A day later, the group says turnaround specialist Phil Roux, who has the backing of the retailers’ guild, rejected its offer to join the board.
M&G is seeking the election of Roux, former PwC chartered accountant and Shoprite lead auditor Anton Wentzel, Spar retailer George Skoutellas, former Media24 chief executive and chief financial officer Omnichand Lalbahadur, and former Spar chief executive Angelo Swartz as non-executive directors. Equity analyst Damon Buss says M&G cannot endorse a director moving from one company’s board to a direct competitor’s board, adding that the firm raised governance concerns when Pattison left Pick n Pay and it learned he was being considered by Spar.
Retailer backing adds pressure on turnaround efforts
Pattison tells Moneyweb he will respect shareholders’ decisions at both the extraordinary general meeting and the annual general meeting before he joins, saying the board’s right to invite him and shareholders’ right to decide who serves are both fundamental to good governance.The standoff comes as tensions between Spar’s independent retailers and its board over leadership come to a head this year. On Tuesday, the Spar Guild of Southern Africa publicly backs Roux, Swartz and Skoutellas for board roles, saying retailers want meaningful renewal of the Spar group board and direct experience of the Spar retail model at board level.
The governance dispute unfolds as Spar struggles with high debt levels, intense competition and pressure on the sustainability of its business model from on-demand delivery services. There are currently no independent retailers on Spar’s board, making representation and operating experience a central issue in the wider debate over the group’s recovery path.
We have also looked at UK grocery competition as discounters gained share amid rising costs and household budget pressure.