Chappal Energies trial dispute deepens as defence exits Lagos court

Chappal Energies trial dispute deepens as defence exits Lagos court
Chappal Energies trial turmoil

A legal battle tied to a shareholding dispute at Chappal Energies is intensifying after defence lawyers for founder and managing director Ufoma Joseph Immanuel leave a Lagos courtroom in protest. The walkout follows a judge's decision to continue the criminal trial despite a separate subsisting order restraining the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, or EFCC, from taking further steps in the case.

Highlights

  • Defence team for Immanuel exits Lagos Special Offences Court after Justice Mojisola Dada orders accelerated trial continuation despite pending applications.
  • October 2026 ruling by Justice Josephine Obanor restrains EFCC from proceeding with criminal charges in Charge No. ID/27000C/2025 until the substantive suit is determined.
  • EFCC filed charges against Immanuel and Intermediate Investments Limited on October 7, 2025, extending Chappal Energies’ corporate governance dispute into broader legal risks.

Court proceedings and conflicting orders

As reported by Businessday, lawyers representing Immanuel walk out of the Special Offences Court in Ikeja after Justice Mojisola Dada directs that the trial continue on an accelerated basis at the resumed hearing on Wednesday.

EFCC counsel Ekene Iheanacho tells the court the matter is set for continuation of trial, but Immanuel's lead counsel, Oluseun Awonuga, objects and says the defence has already filed and served two processes on the prosecution. He says one application relates to a restraining order and the other challenges the competence of the prosecution.

Justice Dada says the processes are missing from the court file. Awonuga says the registrar tells him they must be printed in colour, and he presents the documents in court. He reiterates that the two applications remain pending, saying the first is dated July 3, 2026 and served on July 6, while the second is filed on October 30 and served on November 2.

The defence argues that the order relied upon in the October application bars the EFCC from continuing the charge. Awonuga also objects to Iheanacho's continued appearance in the matter and says both the commission and its counsel have been served with the order.

He further says Immanuel has been admitted to Lagos State University Teaching Hospital, LASUTH, for almost a month under an order of the Federal High Court, and that a subsequent order directs his immediate return to LASUTH for continued treatment. According to the defence, the court does not take either the hospital admission or the later order into account in its ruling.

After making his submissions, Awonuga leaves the court with his team in protest. Justice Dada says Immanuel has 30 days to retain another lawyer if he wishes, and adjourns the case to January 25, 2027 for continuation of trial.

Implications for the EFCC case and energy sector governance

In an October 2026 ruling, Justice Josephine Obanor reaffirms her order of September 11, 2025 and says the EFCC should have challenged it on appeal if it disputed the decision. She says the commission cannot disregard a subsisting order and proceed with criminal charges as though it does not exist.

That ruling stems from a suit brought by Chappal Energies Mauritius Limited, Intermediate Investments Limited and Immanuel against the Attorney-General of the Federation, the EFCC, the Nigeria Police Force, R28 Limited, Biswal Limited and Adebisi Adebutu. The court restrains the EFCC from taking further steps in Charge No. ID/27000C/2025, Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Ufoma Joseph Immanuel and Intermediate Investments Limited, pending determination of the substantive suit.

The order also restrains the commission from relying on specified documents already tendered in the criminal proceedings. Obanor says a subsisting court order remains binding until it is set aside or otherwise lawfully discharged.

The EFCC files the criminal charge at the Lagos State High Court, Ikeja Division, on October 7, 2025. It accuses Immanuel and Intermediate Investments Limited of offences including obtaining property by pretence and forgery, extending a corporate governance dispute at Chappal Energies into a broader legal risk for the company and its shareholders.

We have previously detailed the China investment pledges tied to Philippine manufacturing and clean energy projects discussed after the APEC meeting.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.