Penang insists that no payment is due to Perak before water supply under the Bulk Water Supply Agreement begins. The clarification came as the state government defended the agreement as a measure to strengthen infrastructure capacity and water supply security for the next 40 years.
Highlights
- Payments under the water supply agreement between Perak and Penang will only begin once water is supplied and are subject to SPAN approval.
- The BWSA proposal was approved by all PBAPP board members, and by 98% of PBA Holdings Bhd shareholders at the extraordinary general meeting on 12 Nov.
- The agreement gives Penang access to water infrastructure capacity without bearing the full construction costs or necessarily making payments until 2072 if the terms are breached.
This article was translated from the original. Read the original version by our correspondent here.
Approval details and payment terms
The Edge Malaysia reported that Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow said payments under the agreement would only begin once water supply commenced and would also be subject to approval by the National Water Services Commission (SPAN). He rejected claims that the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) would have to pay RM210 million a year for 40 years without receiving any water, describing the allegations as misleading and unethical.Chow said explanations about the agreement had been provided repeatedly, but Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng continued to claim that the process involved unethical practices. He said the BWSA proposal had received approval from all PBAPP board members, while PBA Holdings Bhd's extraordinary general meeting on 12 Nov also approved the proposal, with 98% of shareholders voting in favour.
He, who is also chairman of PBAPP and PBA Holdings Bhd, said the professional views of the company's five independent directors had also been recorded and respected. The board approved the proposal by a majority vote of seven to five, with the five directors' objections limited to several payment terms, which he said had been addressed through specific clauses in the agreement.
Implications for the state's water supply security
Chow said the agreement between Perak and Penang was important for securing water infrastructure capacity and the state's water supply for the next 40 years, for the benefit of the people, industry, investors and future generations. He also questioned the allegations of unethical conduct against an agreement that, he said, guaranteed long-term infrastructure capacity and water supply.Chow said the agreement also gave Penang access to substantial water infrastructure capacity without having to bear the full construction costs and risks of early development. He added that PBAPP had contractual rights to take action, including invoking the termination provisions, if any breach of obligations was not remedied in accordance with the agreement's terms.
He said this meant Penang would not necessarily have to continue making payments until 2072, as claimed.
We also discussed the broader context surrounding the 40-year, RM24.6 billion water supply agreement between Penang and Perak.