Dormant bitcoin wallet movement complicates New York claim on allegedly abandoned BTC
A Satoshi-era Bitcoin wallet moves 75 BTC for the first time since 2011 after being named in a New York lawsuit over allegedly abandoned cryptocurrency holdings. The roughly $5 million transfer also sweeps up a tiny court-notice payment sent to the address in May, undermining the claim that the coins were effectively lost.
Highlights
- A dormant wallet listed as defendant No. 3,419 in a New York lawsuit moved its original 75 BTC and several small deposits to a new address Thursday evening.
- The lawsuit, led by Noah Doe and two Wyoming companies, seeks control of bitcoin in 39,069 addresses alleged to be abandoned after five years of inactivity under New York law.
- Recent on-chain activity undermines plaintiffs' claim of abandonment, and expert testimony values the wallets at less than $10 due to the uncertainty of key recovery even if the court rules in their favor.
Lawsuit notice and wallet transfer
As first reported by CoinDesk, the wallet, listed as defendant No. 3,419 in an amended New York complaint, empties its balance into a new address on Thursday evening. The transaction includes the original 75 BTC, a court-notice payment of 546 satoshis sent on May 22, and three other small deposits.The lawsuit is brought by a plaintiff identified as Noah Doe and two Wyoming companies, which ask the court to award them control of bitcoin held in 39,069 addresses. Their argument is that wallets inactive for at least five years contain lost property that can be claimed under New York law.
The court allows plaintiffs to notify unidentified wallet holders by sending tiny bitcoin payments carrying messages linked to legal papers. One additional payment spent in Thursday’s transfer carries a separate July 2025 owner notice from Salomon Brothers Strategic Advisors, the consultant hired to contact wallet holders.
Implications for the abandoned-property claim
The movement does not reveal who controls the wallet, and it does not establish whether the lawsuit triggers the transfer. It does, however, weaken the case’s central premise that the coins in the address are abandoned.The complaint targets about 3.8 million BTC, including coins attributed to Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto. Other addresses named in the case have also shown activity, including a wallet that CoinDesk reports in June had held 35.55 BTC since 2011 and spent 15 BTC while returning the rest to itself as change.
Even if the plaintiffs win in court, they still would not receive the private keys needed to move the bitcoin. The complaint says a hired expert values the so-called found wallets at less than $10 because recovery of their contents remains uncertain.
As we noted earlier, dormant Bitcoin wallets moved 100 BTC from 2010 mining rewards into newer SegWit addresses.