Australia mining tax analysis points to $135 billion budget gain
Australia's long-running debate over taxing mining windfalls has resurfaced as budget pressures intensify and the government faces calls to broaden revenue sources. New parliamentary modelling suggests the abandoned Resources Super Profits Tax could have materially altered the federal fiscal position over more than a decade.
Highlights
- Parliamentary Budget Office analysis finds the original mining super profits tax could have improved Australia's budget by $135 billion over 14 years if retained.
- The tax would have generated a net $24 billion in the past financial year, enough to eliminate the government's $22.3 billion budget deficit, according to the PBO.
- The federal government's 2024 tightening of the Petroleum Resource Rent Tax, including capping gas extractor deductions and advancing payments, has collected an additional $1.2 billion.
Parliamentary modelling revives tax debate
As reported by ABC News, analysis by the Parliamentary Budget Office, commissioned by the Greens, finds the mining super profits tax proposed under former prime minister Kevin Rudd could have improved the budget by $135 billion if it had remained in place.The proposed levy, which was designed to tax 40 per cent of mining company super profits, became a major political flashpoint in 2010. A $22 million industry campaign opposed the measure, and the policy's unpopularity partly prompted the leadership challenge that removed Rudd and elevated Julia Gillard, who replaced it with a lighter scheme that was later scrapped after the Coalition won office in 2013.
The PBO says the tax would have raised a net $24 billion in the last financial year if it had been kept, enough to eliminate the government's $22.3 billion budget deficit, all else being equal. Over the 14 years in which the tax would have operated, the office estimates a $135 billion improvement in the overall budget position, while assuming the reform would not have changed mining production, investment decisions or mineral prices.
Treasurer Jim Chalmers declines to comment on the modelling, and the government is not considering reinstating the resource rent tax. Since 2012, when the super profits tax was meant to start, the federal budget has been in deficit in most years.
Budget strain and industry implications
Treasurer Jim Chalmers has warned that pressure on the budget is mounting as borrowing costs rise and aged care and other social payments become more expensive, even with measures intended to save $38 billion over four years from the National Disability Insurance Scheme. The federal government is also under pressure to slow spending as the Reserve Bank warns that limited domestic capacity is adding to inflation alongside international pressures, including the war in Iran.The Greens are using the modelling to argue for a 25 per cent tax on gas export profits and a higher rent tax on offshore petroleum companies. Senator Steph Hodgins-May says the figures show the revenue foregone by governments unwilling to confront large resources groups, while Resources Minister Madeleine King rejects the proposal and says the government's focus remains on securing more gas for Australians at affordable prices.
Industry groups continue to argue that windfall-style taxes risk delaying projects and pushing investment offshore. At a Senate inquiry earlier this year, Shell Australia chair Cecile Wake says a similar tax in the UK contributed to a contraction in investment, while former Treasury secretary Ken Henry reiterates his support for a profits-based resources tax, arguing it is in the national interest.
Australia still has a separate Petroleum Resource Rent Tax on offshore petroleum profits, set at 40 per cent after exploration and other costs. The federal government tightened that regime in 2024 by capping deductions for gas extractors and bringing forward payments, collecting an additional $1.2 billion since the changes took effect.
In earlier coverage, we examined the U.S. economic plan and how its tax cuts fueled budget concerns.