Pavlo Kot

Australia debate over free markets shifts to productivity, taxes and housing policy

Australia debate over free markets shifts to productivity, taxes and housing policy
Australia's shifting economic debate

Australia's debate over economic policy is widening as younger voters show less enthusiasm for free-market arguments and policymakers face pressure over living standards. A note published this week by AMP chief economist Shane Oliver argues government involvement has gone too far, while the broader discussion also highlights contradictions in how economic freedom is measured.

Highlights

  • AMP chief economist Shane Oliver urges Australia to cut taxes, reduce public spending and deregulate labour and product markets to boost productivity.
  • Oliver acknowledges that government intervention remains necessary for addressing environmental risks, monopolies, infrastructure, and the social safety net, emphasizing the need for balance over extremism.
  • Comparison to Singapore—ranked first for economic freedom despite heavy housing intervention—raises debate on targeted regulation to address affordability while sustaining economic growth.

AMP note sharpens policy debate

As reported by ABC News, Shane Oliver says support for free markets is weakening as debate shifts toward redistribution, scepticism of business and demands for greater government action. In a note published this week, the AMP chief economist argues the policy pendulum has moved too far toward intervention over the past three decades and says Australia should cut taxes, lower public spending and remove some regulation from labour and product markets to lift productivity and living standards.

Oliver also says unfettered markets can fail in major ways, including through pollution, monopolies, financial instability and inequality. He argues governments still have a role in protecting the environment, enforcing property rights, providing infrastructure and public goods, regulating monopolies and maintaining a social safety net, framing the issue as one of balance rather than a choice between pure free markets and full state control.

Housing and economic freedom complicate the case

That argument is complicated by the measure of economic freedom cited in the debate. Oliver points to a relationship between economic freedom and GDP per person, drawing on the Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom, where Australia already ranks fourth globally.

The article notes the index tends to reward low taxes, limited tariffs and lower government spending, yet Singapore ranks first despite extensive state intervention in housing and land use. It says Singapore combines open trade and capital markets with government-built housing, broad land acquisition powers, planning controls and anti-speculation measures that have helped keep housing affordable.

That comparison adds weight to a broader question for Australia: whether stronger intervention in selected markets, especially housing, could improve living standards without undermining overall economic performance. In that sense, the debate is shifting from ideology alone to whether specific forms of regulation and public spending can address affordability pressures while preserving growth.

As we noted earlier, Labor’s CGT reform faces Senate uncertainty as the Greens weigh Allegra Spender’s alternative proposal.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.