Tokens without buyers: Why NFT marketplaces are shutting down

Traders Union
All News
Editors' Picks
Tokens without buyers

Blur becomes the latest casualty

Blur, once the largest marketplace for Ethereum-based NFTs, announced that it will close its website on November 12, 2026. Its NFT lending service, Blend, will also stop arranging new loans, although the marketplace's underlying smart contracts will remain operational on Ethereum.

View post on X Loading...

The tweet was deleted by the author.

But we saved everything 🙂.

The closure follows a dramatic collapse in trading activity. Blur handled approximately $1.43 billion in NFT transactions in March 2023, when it accounted for more than 70% of Ethereum NFT trading. By March 2026, its monthly volume had fallen below $7 million, a decline of more than 99.5%.

Launched in 2022, Blur challenged OpenSea with faster transactions, zero marketplace fees, and token rewards designed to attract active traders. The strategy helped it capture market share and briefly dominate Ethereum NFT trading.

The decision also follows the announced shutdown of Blast, an Ethereum scaling network created by the same founder, Tieshun Roquerre. Blast's developers said operating costs had exceeded revenue, although Blur has not publicly attributed its closure to financial losses.

A growing list of marketplace closures

Blur is far from an isolated case. Kraken discontinued its NFT marketplace in February 2025, followed by X2Y2 and Bybit's NFT platform in April. Nifty Gateway, an early destination for high-profile digital art sales, shut down in 2026, while Binance also discontinued its centralized NFT trading service.

The departures have affected both specialist platforms and major cryptocurrency exchanges. X2Y2, once among the largest marketplaces by trading volume, processed billions of dollars in transactions before activity declined sharply.

Explaining the decision to close X2Y2 in March 2025, its founder, known as TP, pointed to the difficulty of sustaining the platform without sufficient trading activity.

“Marketplaces live or die by network effects,” he wrote. “We fought tooth and nail to be #1, but after three years, it's clear it's time to move on.”

The broader market has contracted dramatically. NFT trading volume reached $57.2 billion in 2022, according to DappRadar, while industry estimates put annualized trading activity at approximately $5.5 billion toward the end of 2025. Although the figures come from different datasets, they illustrate the scale of the industry's retreat from its speculative peak.

Why billions in trading failed to build sustainable businesses

During the boom, marketplaces competed aggressively for users by lowering fees, distributing tokens, and rewarding trading activity. These incentives helped platforms attract customers, but they did not necessarily create dependable sources of income.

Blur illustrates the problem. Its zero-fee model attracted professional traders and helped it overtake established competitors. Yet the platform collected no marketplace transaction fees, regardless of how much volume it processed.

For platforms that do charge fees, falling trading activity creates a different challenge. Fewer transactions mean less revenue, while declining NFT prices can reduce the value of each sale. Meanwhile, infrastructure, security, and development expenses remain.

Liquidity is another weakness. Unlike cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, individual NFTs are not interchangeable. When speculative demand fades, collectors may struggle to find buyers, leaving marketplaces with fewer transactions and less opportunity to generate revenue.

Can the survivors find a new business model?

Not every major platform has disappeared. OpenSea remains active, while Magic Eden continues operating after retreating from several blockchain markets. However, both have changed their strategies.

OpenSea has expanded beyond digital collectibles into cryptocurrency trading. In October 2025, Blockworks reported that the company generated more than $25 million in token-trading revenue over the preceding month, compared with approximately $5.6 million from NFT trading. Those figures show how important other crypto products had become, although they do not establish whether the company was profitable.

Magic Eden has taken a different approach. In March 2026, it discontinued its Bitcoin and Ethereum-compatible NFT marketplaces while retaining its Solana-focused services.

Does the technology still have a future?

The collapse of marketplaces does not necessarily mean NFTs themselves will disappear. Tokens held in personal wallets can remain on a blockchain even when the platform where they were purchased shuts down. However, selling them may become harder, and associated artwork or services may depend on companies that no longer operate.

Potential uses also extend beyond speculative collectibles. NFTs can represent gaming assets, event tickets, digital memberships, and certificates. These applications do not necessarily depend on rising resale prices, although they still need to offer advantages over conventional digital systems.

Blur's shutdown illustrates the divide between technological survival and commercial success. The question is no longer whether NFTs can attract billions in trading activity, but whether businesses built around them can generate enough revenue to survive without another boom.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.