Aipac faces election backlash as U.S. primary races test lobby influence
Opposition to Aipac is becoming a sharper issue in U.S. primary campaigns as candidates increasingly turn the pro-Israel lobby group into a liability rather than an endorsement advantage. The shift is most visible in contested Democratic races such as Michigan's Senate primary, where the group's spending and ties to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu are under intense scrutiny.
Highlights
- Aipac spent $46 million in Michigan's Democratic Senate primary, drawing criticism that its influence is alienating voters from candidates like Abdul El-Sayed.
- Aipac raised over $47 million this cycle, with its Super PAC United Democracy Project amassing $80.3 million as of June 30, backed by financiers including Paul Singer and Marc Rowan.
- Political backlash against Aipac intensifies as critics argue its positions align with hardline Israeli policies and are increasingly out of step with Democratic voters and some Jewish Americans.
Primary races put spending under spotlight
As reported by Financial Times, Aipac is emerging as a central flashpoint in several U.S. midterm primary contests, with critics arguing that its financial muscle and policy alignment with Israel's government are alienating voters across parts of the electorate.In Michigan's Democratic Senate primary, progressive candidate Abdul El-Sayed attacks rival Haley Stevens over support linked to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, citing $46 million in Aipac spending in the race. Stevens rejects the charge that she is beholden to the group, saying she answers to Michigan voters, but the issue is taking a prominent place before polling.
The backlash is not confined to Michigan. In a New York City primary, Brad Lander used incumbent Dan Goldman's ties to Aipac as a line of attack in a race between two Jewish candidates with broadly similar positions, helping widen his advantage. Lander says voters are frustrated with candidates backed by Wall Street, crypto, AI and Aipac money.
Aipac remains one of the best-funded political organizations in the U.S. It has raised more than $47 million this cycle, while its affiliated Super Pac, United Democracy Project, reported $80.3 million in resources as of June 30 and is backed by prominent financiers including Elliott Management's Paul Singer and Apollo Global Management chief executive Marc Rowan.
Israel politics deepen pressure on the lobby
Public attitudes toward Aipac are changing as criticism of Israel's actions in Gaza, the West Bank and Lebanon rises and as Netanyahu's long influence over Israeli politics shapes how the group is viewed in the U.S. Critics on the left see Aipac as aligned with increasingly hardline Israeli policies, while some on the right argue its influence clashes with an "America First" foreign policy stance.Analysts and advocates say the strain has built over years. Historians note that support for Israel once sat more naturally with U.S. liberals, particularly in the decades after the Holocaust, but that consensus weakens as Israeli governments move right and Aipac offers near-unconditional backing. Netanyahu's opposition to Barack Obama's 2015 Iran nuclear deal widened the gap with many Democrats, and the creation of United Democracy Project in 2022 intensified criticism of the group's election spending.
Opponents such as Matt Duss of the Center for International Policy and Tali deGroot of J Street argue Aipac's positions are increasingly out of step with Democratic voters and parts of the American Jewish community. The debate is also drawing in broader concerns about money in politics, with Columbia University professor Basil Smikle saying recent contests reflect a wider referendum on large interest-group spending.
Aipac rejects the claim that it acts as a mouthpiece for Netanyahu. Spokesperson Deryn Sousa says it is an American organization focused on strengthening the U.S.-Israel relationship, and adds that 188 candidates endorsed by the group have won in the current cycle while 14 anti-Israel candidates have been defeated. Even so, the organization is facing growing resistance as voters question the role of big-money lobbying in U.S. elections.
Our earlier coverage of Aipac’s role in U.S. primary races examined how the group’s large election spending—and its perceived closeness to Benjamin Netanyahu—has turned it into a polarizing factor in several competitive contests. We noted that as Democratic and some conservative voters grow more critical of Israel’s policies, candidates backed by Aipac face sharper scrutiny and opponents increasingly use big-money lobbying concerns as a key line of attack.