ISS STOXX survey highlights split views on U.S. governance and reporting policies

ISS STOXX survey highlights split views on U.S. governance and reporting policies
Governance views divided

ISS STOXX Governance is releasing the results of its annual global Benchmark policy survey, showing sharp differences between investor and non-investor respondents on key corporate governance questions. The survey gathers 253 responses and is set to inform draft voting policy updates that are due in the coming weeks before taking effect for shareholder meetings from Feb. 1, 2027.

Highlights

  • ISS STOXX survey shows 64 percent of investor respondents support considering board tenure in U.S. director independence assessments, while 74 percent of non-investors oppose it.
  • Fifty percent of investor respondents oppose shifting U.S. and Canadian companies to semiannual reporting due to volatility concerns, whereas 54 percent of non-investors see no issue.
  • Final ISS STOXX Benchmark policy updates, influenced by these divided views, will be released in late November or early December for application to meetings on or after Feb. 1, 2027.

Survey findings shape next policy review

According to ISS STOXX, as announced by ISS STOXX Governance, this year’s Benchmark policy survey spans global, regional, and national governance issues including director independence, shareholder rights, meeting formats, executive compensation, and nature-related risk management. The group says 141 of the 253 responses come from institutional investors and investor-affiliated organizations, while 112 come from companies, corporate-affiliated organizations, and other non-investor participants.

Responses show a clear divide on director independence in the U.S. Among investor respondents, 64 percent say long board tenure should be considered when assessing whether a director remains independent. By contrast, 74 percent of non-investor respondents say tenure should not be a factor, regardless of length, and that a board’s own determination is generally sufficient.

The survey also finds differing positions on shareholder meeting formats in Continental Europe. Only 11 percent of investor respondents say virtual-only annual general meetings are generally acceptable in all circumstances, while 49.6 percent identify hybrid meetings as the preferred format. On the non-investor side, 76 percent say virtual-only meetings are acceptable if shareholders can exercise rights substantially equivalent to those available in person.

Views also diverge on the possibility of semiannual financial reporting for U.S. and Canadian companies. Half of investor respondents say such a move would be negative because less frequent reporting could increase volatility and favor parties with access to non-public information or advanced analytical capabilities, while another 13 percent say it may suit smaller pre-revenue or start-up companies but not larger mature businesses. Among non-investor respondents, 54 percent say semiannual reporting would not be a concern and 19 percent call it a positive change.

Implications for 2027 voting policies

The survey further tests opinion on board responsiveness to executive pay concerns in the U.S. after the Securities and Exchange Commission’s May 2026 proposal to broaden the number of companies exempt from existing say-on-pay voting requirements. Half of investor respondents say that if pay concerns arise and no say-on-pay vote is on the ballot, they would support opposing the compensation committee chair in the first year, while 41 percent support opposing all incumbent compensation committee members.

Non-investor respondents take a different view on pay oversight, with 54 percent saying opposition to compensation committee members would not be appropriate in those circumstances. On nature-related risk disclosures, 68 percent of investor respondents globally say companies with significant exposure should disclose information using a recognized framework, while half of non-investor respondents say that decision should remain at each company’s discretion.

ISS STOXX Governance says it will release key draft Benchmark policy updates over the coming weeks and open a public comment period for proposed changes affecting next year’s voting policies. Final updates are expected in late November or early December, with the revised policies set to apply to shareholder meetings occurring on or after Feb. 1, 2027.

Our earlier coverage of rising global borrowing costs and the bond-market sell-off highlighted the IMF’s warning that higher yields and energy-driven inflation are squeezing government budgets and pushing debt burdens higher. We noted that highly indebted Eurozone countries—particularly France—are more exposed to investor pressure as debt-servicing costs climb, leaving policymakers with less room for fiscal missteps amid broader risks such as sustained high oil prices and rapid AI-driven disruption.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.