U.S. BSL CLO index shows mild credit deterioration as 'CCC' loans reach 5%

U.S. BSL CLO index shows mild credit deterioration as 'CCC' loans reach 5%
US CLOs show credit shift

Early autumn portfolio data show another month of mild weakening in average collateralized loan obligation metrics across the U.S. broadly syndicated loan market. The rise in 'CCC' category assets to 5% marks a high for the year, although default exposure and overall credit quality remain stable.

Highlights

  • S&P Global Ratings reports 'CCC' baskets in its BSL CLO Insights Index have risen to 5% following recent downgrades on widely held obligors.
  • Default exposures and CLO overall credit quality remain stable, with CLO exposures carrying a negative ratings outlook edging down slightly since mid-year.
  • Par loss trends, declining overcollateralization cushions, and ongoing loan price bifurcation continue to drive negative rating actions on junior CLO tranches.

Index metrics and refinancing pressure

As reported by S&P Global Ratings, average metrics across its BSL CLO Insights Index continue to deteriorate mildly, with broadly syndicated loan CLO 'CCC' baskets rising to 5% after recent rating actions on widely held obligors.

Some of those moves involve borrowers either downgraded into the 'CCC' category or carrying 'B-' ratings placed on CreditWatch negative, which are therefore treated as part of the 'CCC' category. Software company Sophos is one example, after its 'B-' rating was placed on CreditWatch negative in mid-August because of refinancing risks.

Although those 'B-' ratings were affirmed and removed from CreditWatch in late September, Sophos was still counted in the 'CCC' basket on many CLO determination dates. S&P said the company ranks 155th on its list of widely held BSL CLO obligors.

Stable broader quality but pressure on junior tranches

Despite the increase in lower-rated assets, default exposures and overall credit quality remain stable, according to the latest index data. The share of CLO exposures carrying a negative ratings outlook has also edged down slightly since the middle of the year.

Weighted average recovery ratings, which have deteriorated steadily over the past five years, have stabilized over the past year. At the same time, loan prices remain bifurcated, while par loss trends and declines in overcollateralization cushion continue, which S&P identifies as a key driver of this year's negative rating actions on junior CLO tranches.

Our earlier coverage of Fidelity Grand Harbour CLO 2021-1 DAC described how additional par losses and a shrinking par-value test cushion kept pressure on the deal even as note ratings were affirmed under updated CLO criteria. We noted that the class F tranche moved to a Negative Outlook, while overall collateral performance was broadly stable but vulnerable to defaults and weaker recovery dynamics—issues that tend to surface first in junior tranches.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.