South Carolina Farm Bureau Group outlook raised to stable as AM Best affirms ratings
South Carolina Farm Bureau Group secures a more stable ratings trajectory after strengthening capital metrics following earlier weather-related losses. The revised outlook covers South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company and Palmetto Casualty Insurance Company, both based in Cayce, South Carolina.
Highlights
- AM Best revised South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Group's outlook to stable from negative and affirmed its B++ and 'bbb' ratings, citing stronger capital metrics.
- Underwriting and risk management initiatives, coupled with lower weather-related losses, support double-digit capital growth projected through full-year 2025 and year-to-date 2026.
- Operating performance remains marginal and business profile limited due to concentration in hurricane-prone South Carolina, leaving earnings vulnerable to severe weather and regional risks.
Rating action reflects stronger capital position
As reported by AM Best, the ratings agency revises the outlooks to stable from negative and affirms the Financial Strength Rating of B++ (Good) and the Long-Term Issuer Credit Ratings of "bbb" (Good) for South Carolina Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company and its reinsured affiliate, Palmetto Casualty Insurance Company.AM Best says the credit ratings reflect the group’s strong balance sheet strength, along with marginal operating performance, a limited business profile and appropriate enterprise risk management. The agency says the outlook revision follows sustained improvement in key balance sheet strength metrics over more recent periods.
Earlier in the most recent five-year period, the group’s balance sheet is affected by sizable losses from Hurricane Helene and smaller weather-related events, leading to reductions in policyholders’ surplus and weaker risk-adjusted capitalization as measured by Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio. AM Best says underwriting and risk management initiatives, combined with lower frequency and severity of weather-related losses, materially improve underwriting results and support double-digit capital growth through full-year 2025 and year-to-date 2026.
Weather exposure remains a key constraint
AM Best says the stronger capital base stabilizes the group’s BCAR position as well as underwriting and reserve leverage measures. Prospectively, the agency expects capital growth to continue and key metrics to remain aligned with its strong balance sheet strength assessment.The agency continues to assess operating performance as marginal because five-year average return metrics trail the composite average, reflecting volatility in earlier years despite more recent profitability. It also cites the group’s concentration in South Carolina, a hurricane-prone market, as a limit on its business profile because earnings remain exposed to severe weather, competition and state regulatory and economic conditions.
AM Best says the group’s enterprise risk management is appropriate, supported by a developed framework embedded in daily operations and aligned with its risk profile.
We have also analyzed Fitch’s move to revise CT Investment Management’s outlook to stable and affirm its special servicer rating in our coverage of CTIMCO outlook revision.