Pakistan tax reform debate shifts toward expanding PRAL and reducing FBR role

Pakistan tax reform debate shifts toward expanding PRAL and reducing FBR role
PRAL may replace FBR

Pakistan's tax administration remains under pressure as weak enforcement, under-declaration and limited coverage outside major cities continue to constrain revenue collection and economic growth. A new reform argument centers on shifting taxpayer-facing operations to Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited, while sharply reducing the Federal Board of Revenue's administrative footprint.

Highlights

  • The proposal advocates shifting Pakistan's tax administration from the FBR to PRAL, which controls data systems and enables flexible staffing, citing at least 15,000 surplus FBR positions.
  • Redirection of 10,000–15,000 redundant FBR staff would target informal economic activity in smaller towns and agriculture, addressing more than half of the economy that currently escapes taxation.
  • The Finance Act 2026’s faceless audits, reliant on PRAL’s digital infrastructure, would reduce in-person interaction and corruption, contingent on PRAL board governance reforms and enhanced independence from the FBR.

Proposal centers on PRAL-led tax administration

As argued in an opinion piece published by Pakistan Business Recorder, the main weakness in Pakistan's revenue system lies in tax administration rather than tax policy, with repeated administrative failures prompting flawed policy fixes to bridge fiscal gaps.

The article says past efforts to address under-declaration have not delivered lasting results. It points to a restructuring plan approved by the then prime minister in October 2019, during the author's eight-month tenure as FBR chairman, that was meant to right-size staffing and improve data management, but was later dropped because of resistance within the bureaucracy.

The proposed alternative is to use PRAL, a state-owned company established under the Companies Act, as the main vehicle for tax administration reform. The argument is that PRAL already manages data systems and taxpayer interaction, and can hire, retain or reduce staff more flexibly than the FBR, which the article portrays as constrained by outdated administrative structures.

The piece estimates that the FBR's workforce of about 25,000 includes at least 15,000 surplus positions. It highlights roles such as notice servers, typists and stenographers as examples of functions made redundant by PRAL's electronic processing systems, and argues that 10,000 to 15,000 staff could be reassigned to document economic activity in smaller towns and cities that currently remain largely outside the tax net.

Coverage gaps and governance changes in focus

Expanding tax enforcement beyond major urban centers is presented as a key economic objective, with the article arguing that more than half of Pakistan's economy operates in smaller municipalities with little formal tax presence. It also points to agriculture, where farmers and consumers bear financial strain while intermediaries, known as Arthis, capture margins without tax liability, as an area where redirected staff could help formalize transactions.

The article also links PRAL's role to the Finance Act 2026 proposal for faceless audits, saying the system's operational backbone would be supplied by the company. In that framework, PRAL is described as capable of handling nine of ten main steps in direct tax administration, reducing face-to-face contact that the article identifies as a major source of corruption and taxpayer harassment.

To support that shift, the piece calls for changes to PRAL's governance, including giving its chief operating officer greater independence from FBR officials and ending the practice under which the FBR chairman heads PRAL's board ex officio. It proposes decentralizing authority across a Tax Policy Board in the Ministry of Finance, an independent PRAL board with a private-sector majority, and a restructured FBR under the name Pakistan Revenue Services.

The article argues that bureaucratic treatment of PRAL as a subordinate IT arm has held back automation, even as artificial intelligence reshapes administrative systems globally. It adds that tax advisors would still retain an important role in return filing and audit disputes, even if automation reduces opportunities for illicit collusion between taxpayers and officers.

Our earlier coverage on Pakistan’s Tax Year 2026 income tax return deadline pressures examined calls from tax experts and business groups for the FBR to grant more time for filings after the final return form notification in early September 2026. It also highlighted taxpayer complaints about recurring IRIS portal glitches and the resulting compliance risks, along with requests to clear pending extension applications submitted through the system.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.