Miami tax preparer ordered to shut down business after U.S. court injunction
Federal authorities are stepping up enforcement against abusive tax return preparation practices as a Miami-area preparer is permanently barred from the business. The court order also requires Aniel Saint-Hilaire to give up more than $571,000 in gains tied to returns that the court found included fictitious claims.
Highlights
- U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida issued a permanent injunction barring Aniel Saint-Hilaire from tax preparation activities and any related business involvement.
- The court ordered Saint-Hilaire to disgorge $571,739.47, representing 59% of his net return preparation fees, after finding 59% of his returns contained fictitious items.
- The case marks continued federal enforcement, with the Department of Justice obtaining injunctions against hundreds of fraudulent tax preparers over the past decade.
Court order bars tax preparation activity
As announced by U.S. Department of Justice, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida issued a permanent injunction against Aniel Saint-Hilaire, preventing him from acting as a return preparer, preparing tax returns, advising others on return preparation, investing in or receiving fees from a tax return preparation business, or working for or consulting with one.The action follows findings in a Magistrate Judge’s Report and Recommendation that Saint-Hilaire filed federal income tax returns using other preparers’ PTINs. The report also found that he prepared returns understating taxpayers’ liabilities by fraudulently claiming items including unreimbursed employee business expense deductions, fuel tax credits, Residential Clean Energy credits and Health Savings Account deductions.
The district judge adopted those findings and entered the permanent injunction sought by the United States. The court said 59% of the returns Saint-Hilaire prepared claimed fictitious items and ordered him to disgorge $571,739.47, representing 59% of his net return preparation fees.
Broader enforcement and taxpayer risks
Deputy Assistant Attorney General Joshua Wu of the Civil Division’s Tax Litigation Branch announced the case. Attorneys Jeremy A. Rill and Hana Bilicki handled the matter for the government.The case adds to a broader federal crackdown on fraudulent tax preparation businesses. The Department of Justice says it has obtained injunctions against hundreds of unscrupulous tax preparers over the past decade, underscoring continuing compliance risks in the tax services sector.
The IRS urges taxpayers to be cautious when choosing a return preparer and points to resources on its website, including a free directory of federal tax preparers, fraud prevention guidance and advice on protecting personal information. The Justice Department also says people who believe an enjoined preparer or business is violating a court order should contact the Civil Division’s Tax Litigation Branch.
In our earlier article, we covered an Ontario court case over unauthorized shoreline work along the Sturgeon River that led to convictions, fines, and court-ordered payments for damaging endangered Lake Sturgeon habitat in a conservation reserve. The penalties targeted The West Nipissing Company Inc., Deep Construction 2018 Inc., and Timothy Zaba, underscoring the heightened regulatory and financial risks that can follow permit violations and environmental non-compliance.