ASIC appeal over Freedom Insurance director case fails in Full Federal Court

ASIC appeal over Freedom Insurance director case fails in Full Federal Court
ASIC appeal dismissed

Australia's corporate conduct regulator has failed to overturn a court decision in its case against a former Freedom Insurance director tied to disputed sales incentive programs. The ruling leaves intact the dismissal of ASIC's proceedings against Keith Cohen while clarifying how conflicted remuneration laws apply under the Corporations Act.

Highlights

  • Full Federal Court dismissed ASIC’s appeal against the ruling that former Freedom Insurance director Keith Cohen was not liable for breaches of conflicted remuneration laws.
  • Full Court affirmed that Freedom Insurance’s sales incentives constituted conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001, clarifying legal standards for incentive structures in the financial sector.
  • Freedom Group entered external administration in February 2020 and was later deregistered, closing a significant chapter in enforcement actions stemming from Royal Commission scrutiny.

Court ruling and case timeline

As reported by ASIC, the Full Court of the Federal Court has dismissed the regulator's appeal against an earlier Federal Court decision that threw out its proceedings against former Freedom Insurance director Keith Cohen.

The Full Court found that the sales incentives offered by Freedom Insurance amounted to conflicted remuneration under the Corporations Act 2001, but it still upheld the dismissal of ASIC's case against Cohen. ASIC had argued that Cohen and former Freedom Insurance consultant Robert Oayda were knowingly involved in breaches of conflicted remuneration laws, and that Cohen had also breached his directors' duties.

ASIC's appeal relating to Oayda was withdrawn by consent on 19 December 2025. The regulator had started civil penalty proceedings against Cohen and Oayda in October 2021 over sales incentive programs run by the Freedom Group between November 2017 and October 2018.

The Federal Court dismissed ASIC's claims against both individuals on 16 October 2025. ASIC then filed its appeal on 11 November 2025, and the Full Federal Court heard the matter on 26 and 27 August 2026.

Implications for financial services regulation

The decision is significant for Australia's financial services sector because the Full Court says it clarifies the law governing the conflicted remuneration regime. That could shape how regulators, insurers and advisers assess incentive structures linked to product sales.

Freedom Insurance had already come under broader scrutiny as a case study in round six of the Financial Services Royal Commission. ASIC says its investigation began before the commission's final recommendations.

The Freedom Group of companies entered external administration in February 2020 and were later deregistered. The latest court outcome closes another stage in long-running enforcement action tied to sales practices that drew attention during the royal commission period.

Earlier, we looked at ASIC APRA FAR reporting changes aimed at reducing compliance steps for accountable entities.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.