The collapse of Greensill Capital continues to drive regulatory fallout across the UK audit sector as authorities complete reviews tied to the finance group's downfall. The Financial Reporting Council has fined Saffery and its lead audit partner over work on Greensill's 2019 accounts, citing serious shortcomings in risk assessment and scrutiny.
Highlights
- Saffery receives a £581,000 fine from the Financial Reporting Council for serious and pervasive errors in Greensill Capital's 2019 audit, with audit partner Michael Di Leto fined £124,000.
- Saffery also settles separately with Greensill's administrators Grant Thornton, with filings showing £71 million recovered from auditor settlements and more than $9.3 billion overall for creditors and investors.
- The FRC fines PwC £2.9 million for its 2019 Wyelands Bank audit and HW Fisher £140,000 for their Liberty Commodities audit, both linked to Greensill's collapse.
Penalty details and audit findings
As reported by Financial Times, citing Financial Reporting Council, the UK accounting watchdog has imposed a £581,000 fine on Saffery for its audit of Greensill Capital's 2019 financial statements, while lead audit partner Michael Di Leto has been fined £124,000. The regulator says the work contained serious and pervasive errors, closing a five-year investigation linked to the supply chain finance company that collapsed in 2021.The FRC says Saffery failed to respond adequately to significant risks in Greensill's accounts, including possible misstatements in revenue and asset values and the risk that management could override internal controls. It also criticises the firm, then known as Saffery Champness, for its assessment of Greensill as a going concern, a key judgment for investors evaluating whether the business could continue operating.
Simon Broadhurst, the FRC's deputy executive counsel, says the audit work was poorly planned and often superficial, with recurring failures. Saffery says the audit fell short of its standards and adds that it has strengthened procedures, training and guidance as part of a wider programme to improve audit quality.
Wider Greensill fallout for creditors and auditors
Greensill, which counted former UK prime minister David Cameron as an adviser, collapses after insurers refuse to renew essential cover for its financing arrangements. The group had been a major funder of GFG Alliance, the collection of businesses owned by UK industrialist Sanjeev Gupta and his family.Saffery also pays a separate settlement to Greensill's administrators, Grant Thornton. While the allegations and amount are not disclosed, administrator filings show £71 million was recovered from an auditor settlement.
Grant Thornton says it has recovered more than $9.3 billion for creditors and investors, although the administration could continue for years after a September filing extends the process to 2028. The UK Serious Fraud Office still has an open investigation into possible fraud at GFG, including Greensill's financing arrangements with Gupta, while the financial regulator closes its separate probe in 2023 without taking action.
The FRC has also pursued other auditors connected to companies linked to Greensill's collapse. It fines PwC £2.9 million last year over its 2019 audit of Wyelands Bank, and earlier this year fines HW Fisher £140,000 over its audit of Liberty Commodities, another GFG Alliance company that relied heavily on Greensill and Wyelands Bank funding.
Previously, we examined Bank of England warnings that private credit and stablecoins can amplify systemic risk through interconnectedness.