Spartan Capital Securities faces $3.18 million FINRA penalty over private placement failures
A FINRA enforcement action targets Spartan Capital Securities over the sale of affiliated pre-IPO private placements to retail customers in 2021. The case includes restitution and fines for the firm, a two-year suspension for former CEO John Lowry, and an industry bar for former acting compliance chief Kim Monchik.
Highlights
- FINRA ordered Spartan Capital Securities to pay $2.18 million in restitution and a $1 million fine for misconduct related to Atlas Funds private placements.
- John Lowry received a $25,000 fine and two-year suspension, while Kim Monchik was barred from the industry, for failures regarding due diligence and disclosure.
- Spartan recommended $24 million in Atlas Funds investments to 186 customers without proper investigation, with markups of 13% to 36% benefiting Lowry-controlled entities.
Enforcement action and misconduct findings
As reported by Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Spartan Capital Securities has been ordered to pay $2.18 million in restitution to customers and a $1 million fine after FINRA found misconduct tied to recommendations of private placements issued by the firm’s affiliates, known as the Atlas Funds. The settlement resolves a pending disciplinary complaint and also imposes a $25,000 fine and a two-year suspension in all capacities on John Lowry, Spartan’s majority owner and former CEO, while former acting chief compliance officer and former chief administrative officer Kim Monchik is barred from associating with any FINRA member firm.FINRA says the misconduct includes failures to conduct reasonable due diligence on the offerings, failures to fully disclose conflicts of interest, and the use of offering documents that misrepresented material facts, in violation of Regulation Best Interest and anti-fraud provisions of the Securities Act of 1933. Bill St. Louis, FINRA’s executive vice president and head of enforcement, says investors rely on brokerage firms to assess recommended investments reasonably and to provide accurate information about costs and conflicts.
Between March and October 2021, Spartan recommended 344 investments in the Atlas Funds, totaling about $24 million, to 186 customers, most of them retail investors. FINRA found the firm did not reasonably investigate the offerings before making those recommendations and therefore lacked a reasonable basis to conclude they were in customers’ best interests.
Conflicts, disclosure gaps and wider industry implications
According to FINRA’s findings, Lowry created and controlled the Atlas Funds while also owning and controlling Spartan, and Spartan acted as the sole placement agent for the funds at his direction. FINRA says Lowry directed the Atlas Funds to charge customers markups of 13% to 36% above the price the funds paid for interests in the SP Venture Funds, on top of disclosed placement and management fees.FINRA also says Spartan and Monchik failed to determine whether StraightPath possessed or had access to shares in the underlying pre-IPO companies, and failed to reasonably investigate StraightPath’s operating history and the backgrounds of its principals. The regulator says they also did not adequately assess offering prices, including whether StraightPath applied markups to the securities it sold to the Atlas Funds.
The offering documents, FINRA says, materially misled investors by concealing who charged and benefited from the markups. While the documents said a third-party affiliate would sell interests to the Atlas Funds at a markup and that the funds would not share in markup profits, FINRA found that the Atlas Funds bought interests directly from StraightPath and then charged investors markups that benefited entities owned and controlled by Lowry.
FINRA further says Spartan and Monchik failed to establish written policies and procedures reasonably designed to comply with Reg BI’s care obligation and to identify, disclose and mitigate conflicts tied to private placement offerings. In a separate criminal case unrelated to Spartan and its former executives, three former StraightPath principals were sentenced in May to prison terms of eight to 11 years for defrauding investors in StraightPath funds, including through undisclosed markups and sales of interests in funds that did not actually possess or have access to shares in the underlying pre-IPO companies.
Spartan, Lowry and Monchik consented to FINRA’s findings without admitting or denying the allegations in the disciplinary complaint.
Previously, we outlined the main factors behind ASIC penalties for unlicensed car loans in Sydney’s consumer finance sector.