U.S. judge allows Education Department to move borrowers off SAVE repayment plan

U.S. judge allows Education Department to move borrowers off SAVE repayment plan
SAVE plan shift approved

A federal court ruling lets the Education Department continue shifting student-loan borrowers off the SAVE repayment plan after the Biden-era program was eliminated. The decision keeps the underlying lawsuit alive while allowing involuntary transfers to more expensive standard repayment terms to proceed.

Highlights

  • Judge Loren Alikhan denied Public Goods Practice's motion, allowing the Education Department to involuntarily remove borrowers from the SAVE repayment plan.
  • Despite initial 90-day and extended 30-day deadlines, borrowers who missed the window remain in forbearance with no clear timeline for transfer to a higher-payment plan.
  • Ongoing litigation and lack of Education Department communication on transfer timing increase uncertainty and operational risks for the federal student-loan system.

Court ruling keeps SAVE transfers in place

As reported by Business Insider, Judge Loren Alikhan this week denied a motion by law firm Public Goods Practice that sought to stop the forced transfer of borrowers out of the SAVE plan.

In her ruling, Alikhan wrote that the plaintiffs did not sufficiently establish harm, allowing the department to involuntarily move borrowers off SAVE. The case remains ongoing, and the ruling does not address the merits of the broader lawsuit, including whether borrowers should receive relief they might have qualified for before the plan was ended.

The Trump administration eliminated SAVE, a Biden-era repayment plan that offered lower monthly payments and a shorter path to debt relief. The Education Department began sending notices in July giving enrolled borrowers 90 days to switch plans, warning that those who failed to act would be automatically placed into a standard plan with the highest payments.

Borrowers face shifting deadlines and uncertainty

Although the department initially stressed a 90-day deadline, that timeline later changed. After the first period expired, borrowers received a final notice extending the deadline by another 30 days and describing it as their last chance to switch before being moved to a standard plan.

Some borrowers who stayed on SAVE beyond that final 30-day period told Business Insider they remain in forbearance and that no action has yet been taken on their accounts. Earlier this month, Public Goods Practice asked for more detail on the transfer timetable, saying in a court filing that the Education Department's counsel said it did not know when borrowers whose 30-day period had expired would be moved to new plans.

The department has not commented on its plans for carrying out involuntary transfers, leaving uncertainty for borrowers and adding operational risk for the federal student-loan system as the litigation continues.

As a reminder, we recently covered GAO oversight risks tied to ICE detention spending and costly unused capacity.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.