U.S. prediction market regulation fight intensifies as CFTC, states widen action
Regulatory pressure on the prediction market industry is increasing after the midterm elections, with both state officials and federal authorities taking new steps against exchanges and specific contract types. The dispute is widening across courts, Congress and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, adding fresh uncertainty for companies including Kalshi.
Highlights
- CFTC halts certification of Trump-related mention markets in November, citing manipulation risks, with Kalshi complying despite disagreement.
- States intensify legal actions against prediction markets: Utah and Louisiana file complaints against Kalshi and others, while CFTC sues 12 states for regulatory jurisdiction.
- Senate passes bipartisan bill barring CFTC-registered platforms from listing contracts tied to terrorism, war, assassination, or outcomes based on individual deaths.
Federal and state actions widen oversight
As first reported by CNBC, the CFTC on Tuesday placed a hold on the certification of markets tied to President Donald Trump’s words in mid-November, extending its scrutiny of so-called mention markets. The agency has said this type of event contract is vulnerable to manipulation, and Kalshi says it is complying with the order even as Chief Executive Tarek Mansour says the company disagrees with the decision.The broader clash between states and the federal government is also escalating. Utah names institutional market maker Susquehanna International Group as a defendant alongside Kalshi in a separate civil complaint filed on Oct. 20, while Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes filed a criminal complaint against Kalshi in March before a federal judge blocked the case from moving forward in April.
Louisiana’s Republican attorney general also files a complaint on Nov. 12 seeking to bar multiple exchanges from operating in the state, and a state judge orders a temporary restraining order that same day against prediction market companies. At the same time, the CFTC sues 12 states as it seeks to defend what it sees as its exclusive jurisdiction over prediction market regulation.
Congress and political pressure build
Congress is also moving to narrow the types of contracts that federally regulated platforms can offer. On Thursday, the Senate passes a bipartisan bill that would bar CFTC-registered entities from listing contracts involving terrorism, assassination, war or military operations, and it also prohibits contracts that are reasonably expected to resolve based on an individual’s death.Political scrutiny of the sector is spreading beyond that measure. Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff send a letter to the CFTC on Monday asking the agency to reverse a directive telling platforms not to geofence offerings when they receive unfavorable court rulings in certain states, while Democratic Representative Ro Khanna calls for Congress to ban sports-related prediction markets entirely.
The regulatory landscape may shift further as the commission itself changes. President Donald Trump sends bipartisan nominations to the U.S. Senate on Nov. 12 to fill two of the four open CFTC seats, while Kalshi on the same day ends its advisory relationship with Donald Trump Jr., citing his venture capital firm 1789 Capital’s stake in a rival platform.
As we previously wrote, a federal judge let New York’s enforcement proceed in the Kalshi case.