Victoria ranks last in Business Council state business policy index, South Australia leads
Australia's business policy divide is back in focus as Victoria again finishes last and South Australia first in the Business Council of Australia's annual state and territory rankings. The index comes as Victoria's major parties offer tax relief ahead of the November election and as planning reforms across several jurisdictions reshape the policy debate.
Highlights
- Business Council of Australia's 2024 index ranks Victoria last and South Australia first on pro-business settings, citing high taxes and regulatory complexity.
- South Australia leads due to the lowest average payroll tax rates, inflation-indexed thresholds, and simplified licensing, while Victoria faces election pressure over business policy.
- Planned Victorian planning reforms set for 2027 are excluded from this year's rankings, but are expected to improve Victoria's standing in future lists.
Annual rankings highlight tax and regulation gaps
As reported by ABC News, the Business Council of Australia's annual "regulation rumble" again places Victoria last for pro-business settings and South Australia first, with the lobby group citing Victoria's relatively high taxes and complex licensing rules. The peak body has ranked Victoria last in every edition since the index began in 2023, while South Australia has topped the list each year.Bran Black, the council's chief executive, says Victoria "continues to face serious challenges" and argues that high taxes and unnecessary regulation are weighing on the state's economy and employment. The ranking is based on the council's assessment of policies such as payroll and land taxes, planning approval speed, licensing simplicity, and the cost of workers' compensation and insurance.
Several jurisdictions improve their position by streamlining planning systems as part of broader efforts to lift housing construction. Victoria is advancing planning changes through its Better Decisions Made Faster laws, but the reforms are not included because they do not take effect until 2027, although the council says they are likely to improve the state's standing.
Election pressure builds around Victoria's business settings
South Australia performs strongly largely because it has the lowest average payroll tax rates and is the only jurisdiction to index payroll tax thresholds to inflation. It also benefits from a simplified licensing system, while the Northern Territory gains ground through efforts to speed up approvals and the ACT ranks highly because it does not levy land tax on commercial property and keeps stamp duties relatively low.New South Wales has also moved to accelerate planning approvals, but its system remains among the most complex and continues to face delays. Queensland and Western Australia rank sixth and seventh respectively, with Queensland marked down for tight retail trading hour restrictions, uneven planning rules and high land taxes, and Western Australia penalised for applying payroll tax to smaller businesses.
In Victoria, both major parties have promised to raise the land tax-free threshold, partly reversing changes introduced in 2024 under former premiers Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan. The Coalition has also pledged to remove payroll tax for private schools and scrap stamp duty for first homebuyers, while Premier Ben Carroll and Opposition Leader Jess Wilson are both pitching their economic agendas to business ahead of next month's vote.
Our earlier coverage of France’s debt jitters examined how political uncertainty and widening concerns over public finances pushed government borrowing costs higher and unsettled investors. We noted that pressure in the bond market was spilling into equities, with the Cac 40 lagging European peers as budget and election milestones approached.